Prison bars

Letter: Should we be allowing prisoners the right to vote? (Update)

We always welcome a Letter to the Editor to share with our readers. This one from Lake resident Ron Chonner. Ed


Dear Editor

I am writing to express my concern over the possibility of convicted criminals being given the right to vote.

It seems obvious that should this be granted, these same convicts will surely be granted the vote in local elections too. And, given the large number of such convicts imprisoned here this, I believe, will have alarming implications for the Isle of Wight.

They’ll vote to relieve the boredom
For we can expect, I suggest, that 100% of these criminals will turn out to vote, if only to relieve the boredom of their lives and perhaps get them an extra half hour out of their cells.

In sharp contrast to the general lack-lustre turn-out by the rest of the Island’s population.

And further, let us bear in mind that the lives and well-being of the inhabitants of our prisons lies less with the guards and more with the handful of master criminals who wield the real power inside the walls.

Influenced by master criminals
Master criminals who can, if they so wish, instruct everyone on how to vote and who to vote for.

Thus we face the nightmare prospect of our local services, and indeed our very lives, being under the direct control of some anonymous (to us) master mind, who will surely manipulate us to suit his own evil ends.

We must put a stop to this before it is too late.

Write to your MP before we find ourselves suffering the awful consequences.

Yours, Ron Chonner, Lake

Facebook reaction
Update 4.Dec.12
Lots of discussion on this on Facebook, brought here for non-FB readers.

FB reaction to Ron Chonner prisoner’s vote story

Storified by · Tue, Dec 04 2012 04:40:54

noDerek Ragnar Rowell
if they have taken the rights of another away then they have no right of there own… although sadly it doesnt work that way anymoreJack Apple Orchard
No they are in their to be striped of thease kinds of rightsStoidi Gnikcuf
depends on what the individual is in for and for how long ,they will only be dis-enfranchised if there is an election whilst they are in prison , unfortunate to be inside on that dayAllan James Marsh Lrps
Yes we should abide by the EU law as long as we are a member. Disenfranchisement can’t really help with the rehabilitation of offenders can it?Andy Roberts
what like all the other countries abide by EU law?Jack Apple Orchard
plenty of mp’s ceo’s and other "pillars" of society , commit crime making them criminals but as we have seen , these people rarely pay for it …. till they are dead . take away andrew turners vote for a startStephen Smith
remember guys jimmy savile had the vote , not sure if i want it anymore nowStephen Smith
If big banking businesses bribed, bullied or sexually blackmailed our politicians into creating laws locking up huge swathes of everyday folk, as well as those who complained about it, who would be left to vote them out of power. Don’t rely on the little squeaky mice who never had the courage to stand up in the first place.David Craddock
I can’t help but say this. That letter is bloody ridiculous. And comments like" Taking the rights of others away". Not everyone in prison is a murderer or a sex offender. Some people need to open their eyes to the world around them, and realise, you can’t put a whole group of people into the same category.Paul Newton
I miss my naive years when I thought politicians were actually working for the good of the population as a whole.David Craddock
what so you think that some crime is victim less even people who are put into prison for ‘minor’ offences are hurting someone somewhere down the line i think maybe you need to open your eyesJack Apple Orchard
lol , we live in britain , all our luxury is stolen .Stephen Smith
I obviously don’t agree. Although I should of thought it through properly before I used a comment from someone else’s post. And for that I apologise. Our country is starting to infringe on human rights, and I guess I don’t like it. Not here to troll, just have my own opinion on our weakening views of human rights. P.s I don’t know anyone in prison.Paul Newton
look at the demographic of prisons and you will find a huge amount of under privilaged and along with them a whole bunch of disadvantaged including those with "learning disabilities" , these guys can’t afford the lawyers that the rich can afford . look at the sentances dished out for low level petty crime and then look at the ceo of the bopal plant in india . the list is endless .Stephen Smith
No what people have got to remember is to get the vote you may have tn do jury services if you are in prison how can they do thatYvonne Sellman
Prisoners shouldnt be allowed to vote,all their rights should be taken away,doesnt really matter what theyve done,they are in prison for a reasonDarren Preston-Ward
i wish my world were black and white like yours , really do , it would be much simpler . unfortunately i have opened my eyes and your simplistic approach makes me feel like the human race is not capable of managing this or indeed any other debate . how can a rich person rape children and the cps do nothing , yet a poor person steals a bit and is imprisoned . i have stated my views on this previously , every law must be obayed and every law broken must be punished . if we lack the will to enforce a law completely then the law should be changed , similarly if a new social problem arises , laws must be made to keep up with the times . this system we have now is just laughable .Stephen Smith
If we hope to re-integrate prisoners after they have paid their penalty for whatever law they broke, we need to give them some sign that they are progressively regaining their rights and responsibilities. Painful as it obviously is for some people, thi…See MoreChris Wilmott
Why not? It won’t make any difference to the outcome of the election as prisoners are not all of the same political leaning.Steve Smith

Image: Trishalyn under CC BY 2.0