One Wight: Lords Vote To Keep Isle of Wight Separate

This in from Andrew Turner’s Office – Ed


Andrew Turner has welcomed tonight’s decision by the House of Lords who voted 196 to 122 in favour of keeping the Isle of Wight separate from the mainland in terms of parliamentary representation.

House of LordsOver the summer the Island’s MP led the ‘OneWight’ campaign which was enthusiastically supported by the Island’s local media, the local political parties, the Chamber of Commerce and many thousands of Islanders and organisations. The campaign culminated in the delivery of a parliamentary petition to 10 Downing Street signed by over 17,500 people.

The Government could still seek to overturn the amendment, but if tonight’s decision of the House of Lords stands, it will be up to the independent Boundary Commission to decide whether the Isle of Wight is represented by one MP or two in future. It would however prevent a cross-Solent constituency, an idea that has met with widespread opposition.

Mr Turner said:

“This decision is quite simply very good sense from the House of Lords. We are not quite at the end of the line because there is a chance the Government could try to have the amendment reversed, but I am hopeful that will not happen, particularly as there was such a healthy majority in the House of Lords with support from all sides.

“The House of Commons never got the opportunity to vote on the specific proposal to keep the Island separate – so even if the Government tries to change this decision in the Commons they may not get it through.

“Many MPs think this is a ridiculous idea which should never have got this far. It will become clear over the next few weeks what will happen next.

“I would like to thank everybody who got involved in the campaign, every single contribution or signature was important. People may have thought that everything had gone quiet, but we have been working hard on this behind the scenes.

“Lord Fowler has been incredibly effective, as has Lord Oakeshott of Seagrove Bay – they have done a great job for the Island. Sometimes putting party politics aside and working on a cross-party basis really is important and the best way to get results.”

Richard Priest, the independent spokesman for the OneWight campaign said:

“This is great news. Although we have not yet won the war, we have won a very significant battle towards getting the special status of the Island recognised.

“I have been very impressed by the way in which the political parties have put differences aside and worked on this together, as well as the support given by other organisations such as the Chamber of Commerce and Island businesses.

“I am absolutely convinced this is the right decision and I hope the Government will now recognise that.”

Image: drljohnson under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
50 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
montana sliver
1, March 2011 3:59 pm

Somewhat of a paradox that 27 toilets are deemed surplus to the Isle of Wight council’s needs, given that the council are so full of s**t.

Stephen
1, March 2011 4:14 pm

Interesting to learn how the toilet cutbacks will adversely affect handicapped people who rely on the Radar key scheme for some freedom and dignity.
I suspect that this category of user is probably invisible to the majority group on the IWC.

Asite2c
1, March 2011 4:18 pm

If these members vote for the closure of 27 toilets they should be ashamed of themselves. I just hope the day will come when some of them will end up in a situation where they are desperate to relieve themselves but unable to use the public toilet as it has been closed. With no other option but to go in a public place, they end up getting… Read more »

DaveQ
Reply to  Asite2c
1, March 2011 4:34 pm

My campaign to get rid of them started a couple of months ago, although there were many comments, most of those who have contacted me have been from the mainland who want the same thing there so I’m helping wherever I can (See Item entitled “Call for an Independent Alliance”) You are 100% right, now is the time to start campaigning for 2013! Good luck

No Loo
1, March 2011 4:35 pm

I watched Pugh on the BBC2 Inside Out program last night saying the Council are in favour of of the the PFI scheme and paying a private company 11 million pounds a year for the next 25 years to maintain the Island’s roads. He reckons this is good value. Once this contract is signed there is no turning back and the Council will have to pay this… Read more »

Lido
Reply to  No Loo
1, March 2011 6:12 pm

Article one, paragraph one of the “How to be a bully – inadequates unite” rule book quite clearly reads that a member can occupy both states described simultaneously. Suggesting that as mutual exclusivity is not relevant, the subject could be both.

montana sliver
1, March 2011 4:44 pm

which leaves us wondering what incentives Pugh and the rest of them have had to enter into such a bonkers plan

donedeal
1, March 2011 5:13 pm

So the council are now closing “only five libraries”. Hooray for them. They tried exactly the same thing under the libs several years ago, which resulted in public backlash & withdrawal of plans. The Cons have done it differently. Threaten to close nine, then “only five” won’t seem so bad & they get what they were after all along.

Pughloo
1, March 2011 5:54 pm

The bully boy is not for turning.

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined