Council officers suspended over Cowes Enterprise College delays

Following On The Wight’s report last week of yet more delays to the completion of Cowes Enterprise College, it has been announced today that two senior council officers have been suspended over the matter.

Janet Newton, the deputy director for schools and education service, has been suspended pending investigation, along with another un-named officer.

Unanswered questions
On 8th November (13 days ago) On The Wight wrote to Leader of the council, David Pugh asking, “What is your view on the failure of senior staff at the council to take control of the building project at Cowes Enterprise College?

“Which of them will you be insisting resigns, or failing that, is sacked?”

Prior to this morning, we had received no response from the Leader of the council to our questions of 13 days ago, save an automated reply stating he’d be out of the office until 14th November, seven days ago.

Belated response
After contacting the press office this morning, we received a belated reply from David Pugh, in which he included the following statement from Steve Beynon, adding that he fully supported the action which has been taken.

Suspended pending outcome of internal investigation
IW Council chief executive Steve Beynon said: “Two members of council staff have been suspended, as a precautionary measure, pending the outcome of an internal investigation into the management of the contract for the Cowes Enterprise College build.

“The Council’s overriding priority is to ensure that the new school building is complete, safe and ready to be used as soon as possible. To make this happen, a new project team has been assembled, drawing on experience from across the local authority. The responsibility for schools capital and assets has been transferred to the Directorate for the Economy & Environment, overseen by Stuart Love.

“The governing body and trust of Cowes Enterprise College have been kept fully informed of these developments and we continue to work closely with them.”

More unanswered questions
On the 8th November we also wrote to the council press office, asking the following questions about Stuart Love, Strategic Director of Economy and Environment.

Stuart says, “Having seen first hand the amount of work that is required to finish off the building.”

Was his first visit only recently?

How many visits has Stuart Love made to site? What dates?

What is Janet Newton’s view on the delay?

The questions were passed from a junior officer to the Head of Press to be dealt with. At time of publishing this article, the council have failed to answer these simple questions.

Background on Janet Newton
Readers may remember that Janet Newton joined the council, to high praise back, in 2009 at the same time of Roger Edwardson. A press release from the council at the time said,

Janet Newton has a wealth of experience in local authority education having worked for a number of councils including Lancashire County Council, and presently, Wigan Council where she is Service Director for ‘Wigan Schools for the Future’.

She has extensive experience of BSF having been a project director in both Lancashire and Wigan and has delivered key note speeches to national audiences on delivering capital projects, BSF, Private Finance Initiatives and management risks.

In the press release Steve Beynon enthused, saying the selection panel were very impressed with the new officer,

Isle of Wight Council Chief Executive Steve Beynon said “Both these roles have vital parts to play in the council’s vision to improve educational standards on the Isle of Wight.

“The selection panel was very impressed by both Janet and Roger respectively who demonstrated a clear passion for the work they do. Both are looking forward to using their knowledge and skill to help improve outcomes for children and young people on the Island and build on our already acknowledged successes.”

Council leader David Pugh also highlighted the vast experience of Janet Newton, saying,

Cllr David Pugh, Isle of Wight Council Leader said “I look forward to working with both Janet and Roger who will both be a major part of the future of education services on the Island.

“Both are vastly experienced officers in local government and I welcome both to the Isle of Wight”

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
28 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
JamesP
21, November 2012 11:40 am

Good to be reminded of Mr Edwardson, who enjoyed similar tax perks to Dave Burbage (Ltd) while being ’employed’ at hideous expense to ‘improve exam results’. Which went well, obviously.

I have more sympathy for Janet Newton, who has worked hard to fulfil some near-impossible briefs. Knowing you’ve been given a poisoned chalice is probably little consolation, but not taking it may be wiser.

Black Dog
21, November 2012 12:21 pm

Time for a clear out and the very expensive deputy director should go along with her bosses Mr Love and Mr Beynon

Employ people who actually know what they are doing (CV’ tend to expand the truth) and actually care about education and the generations that might actually be let down as a result of mismanagement.

The deputy director will go the same way as Mr Edwardson.

John W
21, November 2012 3:58 pm

Also the cabinet member for education should be held to account and step down from the cabinet.

Mike Starke
21, November 2012 4:03 pm

JamesP and Black Dog are spot on. All I would add is a reminder of the old army adage; “There are no bad soldiers, only bad officers.” Now, remind me; who is in overall charge of education? Correct me if I’m wrong, but at the last count I believe it was council leader David Pugh, who even earns a crust as an “education consultant” to his lobbyist… Read more »

JamesP
Reply to  Mike Starke
21, November 2012 8:34 pm

“Comrade Pughtin”

:-)

retiredhack
21, November 2012 5:14 pm

I believe Janet Newton reports directly to Beynon, who is de facto director of education. He should long ago have been demanding a weekly or even daily report from her on this fiasco, whose seriousness was evident to even the most casual observer. His only justification, therfore, in suspending her rather than taking the blame himself would be if she systematically misled him. This I doubt. I… Read more »

John W
Reply to  retiredhack
21, November 2012 5:45 pm

I hope you are not suggesting mr beynon should go, who will do the riverside bookings process then……..

tulsevent
21, November 2012 8:06 pm

Extraordinary that the council should attempt any major capital project without employing their own project manager to make sure that the developers are doing what the council requires and doing it on time.

mole4wight
21, November 2012 9:35 pm

Interestingly the IOW did recruit a dedicated Progect Manager for this project, but Steve Beynon in his wisdom maded the man and the post redundant in early 2011. The responsibility for delivery was seeded to Janet Newton. And to compound this, when Roger Edwardsons was dismissed in late 2011, his entire team and all of his responsibilties were also put onto Janet Newtons shoulders. With regard to… Read more »

Jake_Gully
Reply to  mole4wight
22, November 2012 9:20 am

ICT wise only the physical structured cabling was provided within the building contract. All other provision rests with Gaia – they’ve had everything in place ready for both previous occupation deadlines. I understand that they have now stripped everything out at the main contractors request. With regard to budget, I think it would be unwise to place too much faith on the official press releases. After all… Read more »

mole4wight
21, November 2012 9:54 pm

Firstly sorry for my typos in the previous posting The real reason for the school not being able to move is summed up by Alan Wells’s statement of 30th October on ‘onthewight’ shown below. The school is complete and ready for handover, por was until Stuart Love authorised the ICT contractors to start decommissioning the computer servers in the new building Alan Wells the Chair of Governors… Read more »

Island Monkey
21, November 2012 10:26 pm

The usual Pugh/Beynon shambles. And as ever, they wont be taking any responsibility for any of it.

One would love to be a fly on the wall when local Tory party Chairman Alan Wells (for it is he) has discussions on the fiasco with his old pal Pugh. Just remember – they’re all in it together.

Carolyn Sibley
22, November 2012 8:28 am

I agree with the comment that the responsibility for the whole mismanagement of Island schools including The Cowes Enterprise College, the continuing difficulties in other secondary schools and the difficulties regarding school transport are the responsibility of the chief executive, passing the buck to blame his staff is reprehensible.

rjc
22, November 2012 9:25 am

They don’t call him Step Back Steve for nothing

Mike Starke
22, November 2012 11:08 am

Much to ponder in the useful and insightful postings on this alarming state of affairs vis a vis the Island’s much-vaunted education reforms. One of many concerns this debate raises is the issue of County Hall’s ability and/or competence to monitor major construction contracts. This bodes extremely ill for overseeing the 25-year roads PFI contract, which we now know to be half-owned by what is known in… Read more »

sam salt
22, November 2012 11:26 am

I feel sorry for those being made scapegoats as it appears their workload was just not achievable. The buck surely stops with the Chief Executive and the Councillor in chage of Education and the Chair of Governors for not acting sooner.

playingthenumbers
22, November 2012 12:54 pm

What have we learnt?

That the buck doesn’t stop at the top.
That effluent really does flow downhill.
It really does matter that officials dot the i’s & cross the t’s, despite the PM claiming otherwise.
Quis custodiet ipsos custodes is as true today as its ever been.
The Teflon dons like to hide behind ladies skirts.

mole4wight
23, November 2012 9:52 am

Hi,

Has anyone consider asking Janet Newton or John Brocklehurst where the bodies are buried, as I’m sure that their loyalty to the Council is sorely tested. I would also think that it is highly likely that they have enough information to persuade Steve Beynon, Stuart Love members of the Cowes Trust and even leading councilors that its time to hang up their boots

mole4wight
23, November 2012 9:54 am

I would ask Sally Perry to put this news item on the top of the pile, as it could get really hot

jimmy smith
23, November 2012 12:26 pm

hmmm,

has anybody tried to make contact with them? perhaps these poor souls have gagging orders from the kremlin, sorry county hall!

mole4wight
23, November 2012 12:30 pm

I believe that the Isle of Wight council has twinned itself with Dunny-on-the-wold

septua
26, November 2012 9:43 pm

I think it is quite wrong that Council officers should be named in the press (and OntheWight) as being suspended. This is trial by media before the officer has been found guilty of any misconduct or negligence. The officer should be quietly suspended, and if later he/she is to be sacked then that is a different matter. The officer may be innocent of any wrong doing or… Read more »

jsdeans
27, November 2012 1:12 pm

I am advised the Principal of CEC is safely housed in his new office in the new building whilst his students continue to try to study in a condemned building which is not now nor has it been for some time fit for purpose. Amongst the many questions which spring to mind, two are uppermost. Firstly, how can you run a school when you are not in… Read more »

Black Dog
6, February 2013 10:59 am

Does anyone know if the Council has found the FIFTY SKIPS that have, allegedly, been paid for but apparently not delivered?????

Black Dog
18, February 2013 9:22 am

It has now been almost three months since we found out that the deputy director of education was suspended. What is happening behind the scenes? Is she still suspended? Is she still receiving a full salary? When will this matter be resolved, either way? When is Love going to resign or find himself on the suspended list? As usual with this regime loads of questions and not… Read more »

Jake_Gully
Reply to  Black Dog
18, February 2013 9:34 am

WitWith you on this – it’s all gone too darn quiet! One might suspect there was an imminent election and that CEC was being neatly swept under the rug. Not that anyone would suspect our Council capable of such sleight of hand.

Perhaps Sally & Simon could ask the Council for an update to dispel any scurrilous rumours before they take hold?

Jake_Gully
18, February 2013 10:35 am

Thanks Sally – look forward to reading this.

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined