planning keyboard

Isle of Wight council say lack of enforcement cases is not a failing, but deliberate policy

A softly, softly approach to planning enforcement is the reason the Isle of Wight Council doesn’t serve many notices, it has claimed.

The role of planning enforcement officers is to investigate suspected breaches of permission — such as non-compliance with conditions.

16 enforcement actions in 12 month
Figures from the Department for Levelling Up, Housing and Communities show in the year up to September 2021, 16 enforcement actions were undertaken by the Isle of Wight Council, with only five enforcement notices issued.

The Isle of Wight Council has stressed it is active in planning enforcement and its policy sets out how problems are dealt with — trying to resolve the matter early, by negotiation, before formal notices are served.

700 enforcement enquiries in 2021
The authority has said last year it received, assessed and investigated, if necessary, more than 700 enforcement enquiries.

Of those, a council spokesperson said, 250 cases were taken forward for further action and almost all were resolved by negotiation without the need for formal enforcement action.

IWC: Lack of cases is not a failing, but a deliberate policy
The spokesperson said,

“While it is true few enforcement cases come to formal action or notices, that is not a failing but a deliberate policy.

“It also does not reflect the work that goes into dealing with many other enforcement enquiries and complaints.”

Cheaper and faster to resolve problems by early negotiation
The council said not only is it cheaper for the taxpayer to resolve problems by early negotiation, but it also leads to a quicker resolution.

Where the problem cannot be resolved, the council will continue to serve formal notice, “if it is in the public interest to do so,” the spokesperson said.

Atherfield Bay Holiday Camp
The issue was highlighted at the planning committee on Tuesday, where the controversial retrospective application for Atherfield Bay Holiday Camp was approved.

Cllr Chris Jarman said he was astonished no one had noticed the work at the site before now, which was being built without following all conditions.

Councillors said the extent of the work done was a step too far and questioned how the council could stop this happening again.

No new staff
A pledge was made in September to hire more temporary staff to help with the enforcement workload, but none had yet been recruited.

Town and parish councils are also stepping up, with Newport Community Council proposing the funds for a part-time enforcement officer for Newport and Carisbrooke.


This article is from the BBC’s LDRS (Local Democracy Reporter Service) scheme, which News OnTheWight is taking part in. Some alterations and additions may have been made by OnTheWight. Ed

Image: CreditDebitPro

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
6 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
kerry
3, August 2020 10:10 am

There is plenty of opportunity to build on sites other than green fields, I mean look at the eye sore in Ryde, the disused holiday park just up from Appley beach, why hasn’t that been compulsory purchased? ….and if we are thinking of going green, how about building the very best, high quality, green sustainable houses for the poorest on our island, rather than the cheapest tatty… Read more »

Phil Jordan
3, August 2020 11:36 am

In addition to a range of planning issues which these types of development throw up, we have the ongoing and growing problem of infrastructure. Not just road junctions in the vicinity of developments but further afield from those developments. Through routes in Ryde, as an example, using St John’s Hill and the Queens Road/Argyll Street junctions. Traffic volumes also heading out through to Havenstreet and Brading especially… Read more »

Colin
Reply to  Phil Jordan
3, August 2020 12:46 pm

I couldn’t agree more, Phil.There have been many developments passed with little regard to the impact of the extra traffic. One only has to look at all the industrial and trading estates between the Medina river and Newport which are often gridlocked at going home time. Westridge Cross is already poor and the road down to Smallbrook from that junction is often jam packed. Unfortunately the government… Read more »

YJC
3, August 2020 5:20 pm

All planning applications for building on green or brownfield sites should be delayed until Covid 19 is not a huge threat. Then see how many empty shops and offices there are in the high streets and convert those buildings into affordable houses and flats. Would look much better than empty shops and there will be plenty due to internet shopping and working from home and the change… Read more »

charlest
3, August 2020 9:10 pm

I do not understand why one would willingly build on farm land. We have seen the panic caused by the rumour of a toilet paper shortage imagine what a real food shortage will be like. If we are going to have areas of new development please make sure they add to the environment and our tourist industry with progressive designs and not ‘period’ housing with tiny windows,… Read more »

BigG
4, August 2020 9:01 am

Dear Councillor, people, many hundreds, if not thousands, have been saying ‘no’ for many years past, As an example, Pennyfeathers being at least 6 years past in the making, for all the reasons so cogently and oft stated previously and repeated herein. People raising such eminently sensible objections have been and are consistently ignored. For the Council to state they are merely following government policy ( like… Read more »

Eagle eye
4, August 2020 9:17 am

This planning application needs a judicial review. It has, I believe, been manipulated from the start with the Hope Road development being pushed through. Mr Pink states that the area was deemed suitable for housing – no it wasn’t. The area was outside the development area until the dubious way planning permission was granted for Hope Road. Captiva also claimed they engaged with residents – no they… Read more »

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined