Isle of Wight’s lack of Cabinet member accountability is only example in country, says Cllr (updated)

Cllr Geoff Brodie will be asking councillors to support his motion to reverse last year’s IWC decision to remove accountability of Cabinet members in a public forum. He says the decision was the only known example across LGA authorities.

Geoff Lumley

At next week’s Isle of Wight full council meeting, councillors will be asked to support a motion (originally intended – as reported – for the January 2018 meeting) calling for the reinstatement of their ability to ask questions of Cabinet members in a public forum.

The Conservative majority last year voted to remove that ability and Cllr Geoff Brodie claims that through Local Government Association (LGA) research, there is no known example of this in other local authorities.

Call to reinstate democracy and accountability
He will be presenting the following motion:

Although a minority of Members opposed it, this Council last May voted to remove Cabinet accountability to Full Council in a public forum; a cornerstone of executive governance in a democracy. Research through the LGA has indicated that there is no other known example of this in other local authorities.

Council notes that even the British Prime Minister and their Cabinet are accountable to Parliament through PMQs and regular Ministerial Questions, with the media and public in attendance.

Council does not consider the provision of private Member briefings, written questions to Cabinet members behind the scenes, and questions to Cabinet members at Cabinet and Scrutiny – both relatively poorly attended by the public – to be an adequate alternative.

Therefore, Council agrees in the interests of open democracy to re-introduce an agenda item for Member questions to Cabinet members at Full Council from February 2018.

As usual, OnTheWight will be reporting live from the meeting from 6pm (Wednesday 16th May).

Update: Motion “likely” to be removed
This following is from Megan Baynes (Local Democracy Reporter) as part of the BBC’s LDRS (Local Democracy Reporter Service) scheme, which OnTheWight is taking part in.

A motion calling for the reintroduction of cabinet member questions at full council meetings is likely to be withdrawn.

The motion, submitted by Independent Labour councillor, Geoff Brodie, was due to be debated by councillors at their meeting next Wednesday.

However, Cllr Brodie said he was likely to withdraw it after council leader, Dave Stewart, addressed some of his concerns.

The opportunity to question cabinet members after they had presented their monthly report was dropped last May to leave more time on the agenda to deal with other business.

Currently, councillors can still question a cabinet member on budget and policy at any time and receive a response within five working days.

The response has to be published on the council’s website.

On Wednesday, councillors will also consider amending the authority’s constitution to include an agenda item for a leader’s update report to full council.

If approved, 15 minutes would be set aside to ask questions about the report, with each councillor allowed one question.

Another option on the table is a members’ question time of the leader where councillors have up to 30 minutes during full council to ask written questions and receive responses on any subject.

Cllr Brodie said:

“Dave Stewart has gone some of the way to addressing my concerns. Not all of the way, but I am a realist as well.

“However, it does not say much of his confidence in the rest of his cabinet that he will not let them answer questions.”

Wednesday, 9th May, 2018 1:57pm



Filed under: Island-wide, Isle of Wight Council, Isle of Wight News, Top story

Any views or opinions presented in the comments below are solely those of the author and do not represent those of OnTheWight.

Leave your Reply

6 Comments on "Isle of Wight’s lack of Cabinet member accountability is only example in country, says Cllr (updated)"

newest oldest most voted
Email updates?
The tories don’t care. The electorate are apathetic, numbed by the constant increases in council tax and reduction in services. With one notable exception, the IWC is not interested in engaging with the public it is supposed to serve, prefering to just issue press statements. The ensuing shambles of the lack of expertise and common sense pervades the Island from the queues for the tip to the… Read more »

… we’ll cheerfully vote them all back again – just like all the last times. Now if we had a real leader – but unfortunately Fidel is no longer with us.

Geoff Brodie
This is just a re-hash of the original story from last January, when I first tabled this Motion. I deferred the Motion from the January meeting until May’s Annual Council, next week, to allow discussions with the leadership about getting some improved accountability. There has been some movement, which will be discussed next week, before my Motion is considered. What is said then will determine whether I… Read more »