Stormtroopers

Jonathan Dodd: Volunteering for the Dark Side

Jonathan Dodd‘s latest column. Guest opinion articles do not necessarily reflect the views of the publication. Ed


Most people who know me think I’m an incurable and irrepressible optimist. And they’re right. But if they had known me many years ago they would have had a very different impression. I became cynical and pessimistic at a young age and it took a lot of years and effort to turn myself around.

For instance, I well-remember a time when I didn’t dare to allow myself to be happy. In my head I was sitting very still in a large stone armchair in the dark, and there was a very large hammer poised on a spring above and behind my head. I knew that this hammer was primed to crash down if I felt the slightest hint of happiness.

There was no hammer
I stood sentinel over my feelings for years, and I was miserable. Every time I let my guard slip, sure enough, something terrible happened. But one day I realised that I missed being happy so much that I didn’t care any more, all I wanted was a split second of happiness, and if the hammer fell, so be it.

Stone head:

Of course, as soon as I let myself go, it turned out that there was no hammer and no disaster. It was a spell and I broke it, and from then on I concentrated on becoming as happy as I could possibly be. I can still remember that dark room and the presence of that hammer. That memory is now my key to avoiding ever being like that again.

A fan of the ridiculous
Weirdly, this is what I find myself thinking about whenever I contemplate the state of the world. It seems that people get themselves in such a state of mind that they find it completely acceptable to behave in increasingly ridiculous ways. I have to admit to being a fan of the ridiculous, but not when it’s accompanied by bloodshed.

head in the sand:

It is a fact, that a lot of young men feel they need an outlet for their surplus energy. There are a lot of ways that this can be channelled. Unfortunately young men are not also known for their judgement and wisdom. I remember. I was a young man once. I’m proud of many of the attitudes I took up and still have, but a lot of them make me cringe now. We’ve all been through it.

Their anger and their need to compete
The worrying thing is when this energy and these attitudes stray into dangerous areas. Their anger and their need to compete can have bad consequences. Driving recklessly, drinking too much, tombstoning, all sorts of activities drive worrying parents to distraction. Luckily most young people have well-meaning adults around them, doing the best they can to encourage them to work it all out for themselves without too much damage.

Paintballers:

Mostly this works, and here we all are, surviving and managing. Unfortunately there are people out there who have a different agenda. I see no reason why young people would want to volunteer for battle, where killing or being killed is a reality. Paintballing or go-karting or skateboarding is one thing, but travelling across the world to take up arms seems complete madness to me.

To be and do whatever they want
I hear a lot about the idealism of youth. I remember in my youth the idealism was directed towards stopping wars. We stood up for freedom and a world where everyone respects the rights of themselves and others to be and do whatever they want, as long as that doesn’t involve preventing the same rights for others. Whatever happened to that?

Flower power :

I know a lot of young men travelled to Spain to fight in their civil war in the thirties. Many had high ideals, some just wanted adventure and risk. But they felt strongly that freedom and liberty were being threatened and they wanted to do something about it. Of course when the last war started there was conscription, but generally people thought that the war was just. In previous wars people volunteered because they believed the propaganda, and disagreeing was going to be worse than uncomfortable.

Where are the voices?
What I can’t understand is why young people should go off in droves to fight for a cause that involves killing everyone who disagrees with you, the removal of all the liberties that have been fought for all these centuries, Women voting :and aims to return the world to a state of medieval religious intolerance and ignorance, where the equality of women and the right to education and free speech are removed.

How is it that these young people are allowing themselves to be hoodwinked into thinking that this will solve all their problems, real and imagined? How are they letting themselves be recruited to fight and kill and be killed by old men with a desire for unlimited power? Where are the voices of their parents and teachers in all this?

Are they stuck in some terrible dream?
I was struck by a thought the other day. Who would volunteer to be a storm trooper in Star Wars? They’re so obviously on the wrong side, they’re going to lose, they support leaders who don’t care in any way for them. Have they no brains? Do they have no independent thoughts? Are they stuck in some terrible dream like I was for a while?

Pink stormtrooper :

I am an incurable and irrepressible optimist, but not in a soft way. I believe that good and right always win in the end. I believe that evil springs up when good people stop paying attention, and I believe that combatting evil is hard and dangerous and utterly necessary. It’s far better and cheaper to ward off evil before it takes hold, but we never learn that lesson.

As they say about every war, it’ll all be over by Christmas. Ho, ho, ho!

If you have been, thank you for reading this.


Image: JD Hancock under CC BY 2.0
Image: Mstyslav Chernov under CC BY 2.0
Image: bohringer friedrich
Image: Toni Castillo Quero under CC BY 2.0
Image: CactusWriter under CC BY 2.0
Image: Bkwillwm under CC BY 2.0
Image: bayerberg under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
10 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
skippy
13, July 2014 10:18 am

Unfortuneley there is a a fine line between passion and being fanatical about something these days.

Cynic
13, July 2014 10:56 am

Perhaps Jonathan Dodd’s thoughtful article missed out one aspect of adolescence- the search for identity. That desired identity might be similar to that of their parents or often completely different in the spirit of natural youthful rebellion- one that often weakens as the person grows older and has responsibilities. The search for identity often leads them to join groups that appear to offer the desired identity, especially… Read more »

tryme
13, July 2014 11:47 am

I thought Jonathan was leading on to say that all wars are ridiculous and based on hoodwinking the young and harnessing their lack of appreciation of their own mortality. I’m not sure that saying western wars have been different in that our soldiers ” felt strongly that freedom and liberty were being threatened and they wanted to do something about it”, marks them out very differently from… Read more »

Mark Francis
14, July 2014 9:31 am

I don’t notice any of these bold jihadis taking on Israel when it has just killed nearly 180 people in shelling Gaza. It seems they fell better suited to murdering innocent people in Pakistan or Kenya, Syria or Iraq. I do hope that our own terrorists have not wasted their money on return ticket. Hopefully the Pakistan Army in North Waziristan is currently giving them what they… Read more »

Paleo
Reply to  Mark Francis
14, July 2014 10:46 am

Very thoughtful piece. I volunteered for the TA in 1978 when I believed the Soviets and the Warsaw Pact were an existential threat to my family and community and I wanted to do something, however small, to prevent this. (Running around with guns legally also was a driver for this 18 year old) I left the TA after the wall came down and the socialist mass murderer… Read more »

Cynic
Reply to  Mark Francis
14, July 2014 11:30 am

Perhaps if the “jihadis” in Gaza were funded on the same scale as the US funds Israel- perhaps they would?

(BTW I have no faith that either party really wants peace in that region.)

Cynic
Reply to  Cynic
14, July 2014 11:33 am

@paleo. Blair was not a socialist but a closet Tory as his post-politics career indicates.

Mark Francis
Reply to  Cynic
14, July 2014 11:41 am

What’s he doing now?
Middle-East Peace Envoy wasn’t he?

I wonder how that’s coming along…

Cynic
Reply to  Mark Francis
14, July 2014 1:01 pm

Making money- see todays Telegraph article “Tony Blair’s fortune boosted £13m by ‘bumper year” – while ducking and diving (aided by Cameron) to avoid the truth about the Iraq War coming out in the Chilton Inquiry report.

septua
15, July 2014 9:47 am

The problem with young men from the Middle East, or from families originating there, is a cultural one. Their cultures, whilst very similar, can vary from one country to another, but the similarities are basically that they are spoiled by their families, remain adolescent until well into their 40s, do not respect women or that women should have rights, and their mothers do not have an equal… Read more »

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined