Totland Bay Landslide

Ramblers’ President says urgent action is needed at Totland sea wall (updated)

The President of walking charity, The Ramblers, made a visit to the Isle of Wight last weekend and was given a guided tour of the Totland landslide.

Kate Ashbrook said the situation at Totland – which has seen the coastal path closed since a landslide in December 2012 – requires urgent attention.

Decision deferred
At last month’s Executive meeting, members voted for a second time to defer a decision on what to do next, whilst more precise costs for the proposed ‘make and mend do’ option were gathered.

It appears the figures were not prepared in time for the August meeting, but the item will be discussed on 9th September.

When asked why the decision had been deferred again, the council replied,

“As there are many calls on capital funding across the council at present, Executive members requested details of these projects so that they could be considered alongside the Totland sea wall repairs.

“Executive members agreed with officers to consider the report in September when more detailed information about the competing calls on the council’s capital programme would be available. The Forward Plan was amended to reflect this decision.”

Failure to reopen path would be “severe blow”
Kate finishes her report on the visit by saying,

“The council has a chance to put things right. Let’s hope it seizes the opportunity on 9 September and agrees to invest in reinstatement of a path.

“Failure to do so would be a severe blow to the Island’s economy and to the enjoyment of its residents and visitors.”

‘Make and mend do option’ a “sensible approach”
Speaking on the ‘make and mend do option’, David Howarth, chairman of the Isle of Wight Ramblers, told OnTheWight,

“I think it is a sensible approach in the short to medium term. The Council do have limited funds but need to take action now. The repairs should be done whilst the weather is fine. No contractor will want to work there in poor weather.

“I am concerned about the safety of the closed path. I regularly see children playing on the dangerous landslip.

“In fact the Coastguard were called to an incident there yesterday afternoon.”

A ‘no-brainer’
As previously reported, locals have campaigned hard for the council to take action. A petition was organised by Helen Wood, which gathered over 4,000 signatures and forced a discussion in the council chambers,

Helen told OnTheWight,

“We are very disappointed at yet further delay. People coming to walk the Island’s footoaths, whether locals or tourists, expect well maintained accessible footpaths.

“Time and time again I hear annoyance and frustration over the Totland Sea Wall situation. Despite this, I’m convinced that good sense will prevail and our elected councillors will support the call from over 4,000 petitioners.

“The proposed ‘make do and mend’ scheme is a no-brainer with many benefits and no disadvantages, it’s cheap, effective, quick and what the people want”

You can read Kate’s report of her visit in full by visiting her blog.

Image: © Isle of Wight Council

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
11 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Steve Goodman
12, August 2014 9:25 am

Were we not told that our footpaths would be maintained for 25 years under the PFI contract?

76offset
12, August 2014 10:39 am

Creative thinking, or Common sense ? (From 29.Jun.2013) People are now unable to use the coastal path between Colwell and Totland because of the large landslip at the headland effectively dislodging the seawall. Given time. people would in any case create a natural rough path route, they would find a way through. But with the prospect of access being denied to the public for some years to… Read more »

phil jordan
12, August 2014 11:55 am

76offset: The seawall is not part of the footpath network covered by the PFI contract. It is a right of way, however. The solution we are seeking to get approved is for a re-instatement of a flat footpath between Colwell and Totland along the existing seawall. It is not for a £2.1M rebuild of the breached seawall. I’ll assume you have actually seen the site but if… Read more »

Colin
12, August 2014 1:10 pm

Don’t all hold your breath waiting for any action. The council have hidden behind a Temporary Closure notice on the public right of way that is Whale Chine steps for almost ten years. On checking with the council website I note that this has been upgraded to permanent closure under a Traffic Regulation order. Kept that one quiet didn’t you. So when was this permanently closed Mr.… Read more »

Jon Combe
Reply to  Colin
12, August 2014 11:08 pm

It’s not quite a permenant closure. A permenant closure could only be done with consulation and having proved the path was no longer needed. The law they have applied is a “Prohibition of Pedestrians Order” under the Road Traffic Regulation Act of 1984. This means they can avoid formally closing the path but make it illegal for the only class of user that was ever permitted to… Read more »

Jon Combe
12, August 2014 8:15 pm

Sadly I suspect this can be another path to be added to the increasing list of bits of coast path that the IOW council no longer bother to reapir despite being rights of way and IOW council having an obligation to maintain and protect. I believe this now covers:- * Bembridge Forelands (path BB10) * Gurnard Sea Wall (path CS35) * Totland Sea Wall (T34) * Thorness… Read more »

derek
Reply to  Jon Combe
12, August 2014 10:12 pm

The South West Coastal Path has just received £1,114,000 of Government Funding for urgent repairs to the path,information boards,signage and marketing.

Matthew Chatfield
Reply to  Jon Combe
12, August 2014 11:11 pm

Oddly enough public rights of way is one part of the council’s work that does have an independent group with the duty to hold it to account. This is the Local Access Forum, which meets several times per year and is made up of landowners, user groups, farmers and special interest groups – and even a couple of politicians. You can find out more about them and… Read more »

Colin
Reply to  Matthew Chatfield
13, August 2014 10:03 am

@Matthew

Thanks for that link. I shall be contacting the Forum.

Jon Combe
Reply to  Matthew Chatfield
13, August 2014 12:56 pm

Matthew Chatfield : Yes I’m aware of the Local Access Forum. They have certainly tried to hold the Isle of Wight council to account over the various footpaths that are not being repaired. For example in one of the older meetings a member resigned from the forum specifically over the lack of repairs to Whale Chine. However the Council still did not take any notice.

red4
13, August 2014 8:35 am

I agree with Phil Jordan. This situation occurred following a doubling of normal rainfall. So drainage is essential. The 1924 drainage was found to be blocked. A drainage scheme at Brook Chine has been very effective at reducing the erosion of the cliff there. One cubic metre of water weighs 1 tonne, so there must have been thousands of tonnes pressure on the cliff at Totland when… Read more »

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined