At Wednesday’s full council meeting, Julia Hill from Wight Residents against Asphalt Plant (WRAP) raised further concerns about the proposed asphalt plant applicant and PFI Highways contractor, Eurovia (Vinci Group).
She revealed that the Court of Appeal in Lyon, France, has confirmed the conviction of Eurovia for failing to ensure the protection of a road worker who died of skin cancer, awarding the victim’s widow massive compensation of €155,000.
Vinci Eurovia found guilty of gross negligence
During public question time, Julia addressed Cllr George Brown, saying, “WRAP are extremely concerned at reports in the French media that Vinci Eurovia were found guilty of gross negligence at the appeal court in the case of a worker who died of cancer through exposure to asphalt.
“WRAP’s concerns are heightened by reports that Eurovia are continuing to deny the link between asphalt and cancer, notwithstanding the court’s findings and despite the latest scientific evidence. WRAP is concerned that Eurovia is using the complexity of the environmental permitting process to attempt to secure permission to operate the asphalt in the midst of a residential area.”
Reassurances sought from council
She went on to say, “What reassurance can residents be given that every aspect of Eurovia’s industrial asphalt-making process will be fully and independently reviewed, so that the health interests of Islanders will take precedence over the profit of the off-shore multi-national?
“And, given the complexity of the planning application and permitting process, will this council appoint one individual to oversee an end-to-end approach rather than the current piecemeal way of doing things?”
Legislation will control emissions
Cabinet member for Resources, Cllr George Brown replied, “Emissions are controlled very strictly and specifically by legislation. This is a very important aspect of the planning application which is before the local authority and can give every assurance it will be dealt with the greatest care and greatest attention.”
Julia asked again whether one person would be appointed to oversee an end-to-end approach.
Cllr Brown replied, “The planning process is very strict and very precise and in this case, as in all others, it will be followed exactly.”
Background on the French case
The court case that Julia Hill referred to was reported in French media last week.
For the benefit of those who do not speak French, here is the translated version which explains that the court condemned Eurovia of committing an inexcusable crime and that the company had not taken the necessary action to protect the worker.
Image: Steve Punter under CC BY 2.0
