Rally sign on cardboard which reads to be silent is to be complicit

Letter: Do our MPs have the experience, background and integrity for the job?

News OnTheWight always welcomes a Letter to the Editor to share with our readers – unsurprisingly they don’t always reflect the views of this publication. If you have something you’d like to share, get in touch and of course, your considered comments are welcome below.

This from Peter Geach. Ed


When we watch Prime Minister’s Question Time on a Wednesday, the Opposition MPs in particular, with a belly full of food and drink at taxpayers expense ably led by the Prime Minister; I think we already know the answer to that question.  No sign of austerity or even moderation here; never has been.

The racket and barracking would challenge the noisiest pub at chucking out time.  The Prime Minister blusters and doesn’t answer questions.  The Speaker allows him to do that and ridicule the Parliamentary process.

No actual experience of how general population progress
Many Government MPs have benefitted from an exclusive education and upbringing in influential families that have been able to put their children into positions leading to well paid influential careers.  Many of the Cabinet are multi-millionaires. 

That doesn’t mean they are bad people, some are very bright.  But they have no actual experience of how the general population progress.

They have done very well for themselves and think anyone else can do the same through hard work and insight.  But we can’t all be window cleaners. Not enough ladders to go round for one thing.

Where will get the Engineers?
An effective Industry needs people to work together in teams; degree-level Engineers, Designers, Technicians and highly skilled Craftsman, with Managers who have come up through the ranks and know the business.

MPs spout about Green Energy and the high tech jobs it will provide.  But where will we get these Engineers.

After WWII, we had it made; our Aerospace Industry was world leading in some areas; we had to prioritise. 

Hard-won technology given to Europe
In the face of joining the EU, the UK gave much of its hard won technology to Europe under the guise of collaborative programmes.  Interestingly, Bristol Aircraft wanted to design a larger six-engine Concorde as it became known.  France wanted a smaller aircraft; hence the four-engine version. 

It had Olympus engines which were to be developed for the TSR2 Supersonic Bomber.  But on cancellation of that project by Labour; the cost of developing these engines had to be bourn by the Concorde project; hence the huge cost over run.  Politicians again not thinking things through and making half-informed decisions.

A recipe for disaster?
Labour and Conservative Governments starved our World-leading Nuclear Industry of work, with no new Nuclear Power Stations.  We now have to rely on France and China.  Our Nuclear Industry will surely slowly rebuild over Johnson’s pledge to build a Nuclear Power Station a year.  But where are the experienced Engineers to come from to oversee these immense projects? 

Building in ignorance without being overseen by professional and experienced personnel is the recipe for disaster.  And any Prime Minister who is so ignorant of the consequences shouldn’t be in government.

Ignorance was not the only driver
Both of the main parties must take responsibility for the sorry dilemma they have put this country in.  They threw everything away. 

I don’t think ignorance was the only driver.

When considering most MPs background, this shouldn’t come as a surprise.  A good many are unemployable. The Palace of Westminster could be aptly described as the Drones Club.  See PG Wodehouse novels.

So what do we get from our MPs that is so extraordinary as to warrant £205k per annum expenses for Bob?  I would say not very much.  These colossal expenses compare with an average Island wage of about £20k.

IW has consistently had inadequate funding
It is part of unwritten Conservative folk law that if you don’t vote for a Conservative MP, a Tory Government is unlikely to provide adequate funding. 

Well we have consistently; and consistently we have had inadequate funding.  The levelling up fund for the Island was derisory.  And our Harrow-educated MP on £205k expenses couldn’t do better for us.

Time for change?
Surely time for change.  Another unwritten Conservative folk law is if it doesn’t work fix it.  Well they haven’t fixed Boris, so why should they worry about Bob. 

After all he’s bringing home the bacon; and whilst we continue to vote Tory we’ll keep getting  worked over.

NHS being quietly privatised
Although our NHS is receiving vast funding; much is being quietly privatised.  Diabetic Eye Screening when run by NHS used to visit Island Medical Centres; now it’s privatised the locations are greatly reduced;  now near a major town’s too far to walk for most who are usually elderly.  Considering the process requires eye drops that effect vision for a few hours you can’t drive.

Much of St Mary’s estate around the Diabetic Centre has been sold off.

Covid Testing has stopped.  And hey presto Covid cases have fallen; but magically Hospital Wards are again full.  Older patients in recovery are going into Care Homes!

How does the Government get away with it?
Need to see a Doctor; you need to do a pretty please with the telephone receptionist!  Soon they’ll be asking a number of questions which decide whether you do or don’t see the doctor.

And what of the House?  Politics there seems to concentrate on Personality; not the main issues like The Police Bill; NHS Bill and Social Services Bill; where if you lose your job you have to find a new one; any job at min wage; up to 30 miles from your home, in I think, two weeks otherwise benefits will stop.

Completely out of touch
Don’t see Bob standing up for Islanders pointing out the 30 mile radius for his constituents means a Solent crossing, the fare costing about two hours at min wage.

But then at £205k expenses, he’s completely out of touch; does he care; answer on a postage stamp please.


Image: ehimetalor akhere unuabona under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
10 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
I do not believe it
5, October 2015 6:53 pm

Some things in life are entirely predictable. One of those highly predictable things is the undeniable fact that, if there is even the remotest chance of someone grabbing the wrong end of a stick and spouting malinformation, that person will undoubtably be wearing the East Cowes Mayoral Chain around her neck.

davee
5, October 2015 7:44 pm

No one seems to mention the waste water treatment plant,(if that’s what it is) nicely hidden south of the trees at Castle Point. I notice that the sign on the entrance gate has been removed. On admiralty chart,s the N end of the outfall pipe used to be marked as an “Obstruction”, it is now marked as a “Diffuser”. I wonder what comes out of the outfall… Read more »

Tosh
5, October 2015 7:53 pm

thanks to Cllr Hillard for bringing this to our attention . I have lived in East Cowes for the past 30 years and the EC smell has been here for as long as I can remember most off the smell comes from rooting seaweed from may to September when the seaweed dies back .As for our local council doing anything for the town please don’t hold your… Read more »

Tosh
5, October 2015 7:57 pm

sorry after land slip it should read have they just stood back

timexnewport
5, October 2015 9:12 pm

Having been badly stunk off East Cowes a couple of times and then done some research, my observation is that it might be worth exploring a proper bit of research into the bacteria of the East Cowes beaches. But to save money get all of the potato+ rocks off the area and simply chain harrow the beach for many low tides, especially at low tides when sunshine… Read more »

Michael Douse
6, October 2015 9:31 am

We have arranged another Community Beach Clean at the East Cowes Esplanade under the auspices of Surfers Against Sewage and CPRE

Please love your beach, come along and join in.

Meet at the Esplanade car park at 1.30pm on Saturday 24 October 2015.

Bring work gloves and wellies if you can.

Supervised dogs and children very welcome!

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  Michael Douse
6, October 2015 6:06 pm

I have added to our event listings for you Michael.

sandancer
6, October 2015 4:17 pm

I am part of a group of volunteers called FAECES (not a very nice name, but effective). We noticed about 18 months ago what we took to be raw sewerage coming out of the CSO (Combined Sewage Outfall) off Albany Green. This was happening several times a day and we started photographing it, and then reporting it to the Environment Agency on 0800 80 70 60. This… Read more »

sandancer
6, October 2015 4:18 pm

It has just been brought to my attention that the Town Clerk, Tina Bailey, has just published the October Agenda for the East Cowes Town Council Meeting before a Rescission Notice could be submitted. Bathing water will therefore not be on the agenda (and we will miss the deadline). We need everyone who is vaguely interested to push for an extraordinary meeting specifically for this item. The… Read more »

retired Hack
Reply to  sandancer
6, October 2015 6:29 pm

Lin, you need to consult the ECTC’s standing orders (which should be on the website but don’t appear to be – they must certainly be available from the clerk on request), and ascertain the procedure for getting an extraordinary meeting. I think you’ll find it requires a stated number of councillors to requisition one; and if that is done, with the subject matter stipulated, then neither the… Read more »

Michael Douse
6, October 2015 5:37 pm

On what basis has the East Cowes Town Clerk been able to publish the Agenda for this month’s Full Town Council Meeting more than 24hours before the deadline for submission of items?

Has the Agenda actually been “published”?
It is not on the ECTC website nor is it on the ECTC notice board.

sandancer
7, October 2015 8:09 am

The agenda is now on the ECTC website and Notice Board. It is dated 6th October for a meeting advertised for the 15th October. This means that the time for agenda items to be included was closed one day early. We therefore request that the agenda is reopened to accept a Rescission Notice for discussion and the DEFRA Water Quality Designation bid item is included.

Steve Goodman
7, October 2015 9:34 am

There seems to be more than one stink in E.Cowes. Residents, businesses, and authorities start working to do something to improve things for everybody, and make good progress: sudden u-turn and withdrawal of support from the council: mayor makes false claims: council refuses to deal with the matter: the threat of a missed deadline wasting all the time, effort, and money put in by those trying to… Read more »

sandancer
7, October 2015 10:01 am

The majority of East Cowes Town Councillors want this to Rescission Notice to be included on the Agenda. We attended a recent Town Council meeting where the Mayor was absent. The meeting was quorate but the Town Clerk, Tina Bailey refused to have a discussion about the DEFRA bid without the presence of the Mayor, Margaret Webster. Also absent at that meeting was Peter Lloyd and Jane… Read more »

sam salt
7, October 2015 11:59 am

Unfortunately the ultimate responsibility for putting together the agenda for any lower tier council is that of the Clerk. They should of course work in partnership with the Chairman/Mayor on this but some do not. Below are the requirements as set down by the Local Government Association in respect of calling a meeting and posting the agenda: “The minimum three clear days for notice of a meeting… Read more »

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  sam salt
7, October 2015 12:14 pm

A very informative and helpful response Zzzz!

sam salt
Reply to  Sally Perry
7, October 2015 12:33 pm

Thank you Sally. My personal view is that those Town and Parish Councils that work in partnership with the public achieve so much more than those that don’t. This has been proved by David Bartlett and Ventnor TC. David with his open and frank manner has made community working benefit Ventnor more than anyone could of have imagined. Some 6 or 7 years ago one would never… Read more »

I do not believe it
Reply to  sam salt
7, October 2015 12:47 pm

The fact that East Cowes Town Council is dominated by a self seeking cabal is, at last, slowly emerging.
The manner in which the town’s affairs are very often conducted are a disgrace.

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  sam salt
7, October 2015 1:04 pm

Yes, David Bartlett has really positively turned things around at VTC. From memory, his predecessor is the East Cowes town clerk.

sam salt
Reply to  Sally Perry
7, October 2015 1:30 pm

Yes Sally your memory serves you right.

sandancer
7, October 2015 12:53 pm

Thank you very much Zzzz’s for your very helpful information. Our Town Clerk has obviously misunderstood. She has made 3 clear days this week and 3 clear days next week. Please correct me if I am wrong. If there are 3 clear days next week, Monday, Tuesday, Wednesday, which there are before the meeting on Thursday 15th, the last day for Agenda items will be Friday when… Read more »

sam salt
Reply to  sandancer
7, October 2015 1:30 pm

Lin, if I have read the rules correctly then yes you are right. If the meeting notice is posted on Friday with a meeting the following Thursday then the Monday, Tuesday and Wednesday are the 3 clear days. The Clerk has the ULTIMATE SAY of what appears on the agenda, but a good clerk works with the Mayor or Chairman. There is a rule to get round… Read more »

Luisa Hillard
Reply to  sam salt
7, October 2015 5:39 pm

I believe that you are right about using documents from other Councils as having just read two policies, one talks about a “Complaints Committee” that we don’t have as a Town Council but almost certainly need, and another talks about “Democratic Services” which we also don’t have and so would appear to be the IWC recording policy. I do not recall adopting them anew each year. The… Read more »

sam salt
Reply to  Luisa Hillard
8, October 2015 5:07 pm

I was forwarded a copy of the Standing Orders for East Cowes TC. They were dated May 2014 although no date of adoption was included. I checked the minutes for May 2014 and the Standing Orders were accepted by the Councillors save for an amendment at 10b. This amendment was to limit the Mayor’s term to 2 years. No amendment had been made in the Standing Orders.… Read more »

sandancer
7, October 2015 3:08 pm

Zzzz. Again, thank you very much for all that information. The problem in East Cowes is that the Mayor and Town Clerk work too closely together as a sort of obstructive ‘tag-team’ to the detriment of the residents.

Julian Adams
7, October 2015 10:39 pm

I really hope that the stench of East Cowes beach can be solved and I welcome the current interest. Didn’t the harbour master undertake to remove any seaweed build up when the breakwater was built?

electrickery
Reply to  Julian Adams
19, July 2018 5:04 pm

I hope no-one is relying on either Cllr Webster or the Harbour Master for positive action in the community interest.
The HM will not want to admit that his vanity project might be causing the problem (he has enough complaints about it already!)
As for the Lady Mayor – ask anyone involved with governance of Queensgate School.

isleofwighter100
19, July 2018 11:21 am

NO IT’S NOT SEAWEED! So delighted to see your comments, and your efforts to get something done about the sewage stench in East Cowes. No, it is not seaweed, it is the stench of treated sewage and We should not have to put up with it! I am always pleased to invite friends and family across to show off this beautiful island, but so saddened to have… Read more »

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined