OnTheWight always welcomes a Letter to the Editor to share with our readers – unsurprisingly they don’t always reflect the views of this publication. If you have something you’d like to share, get in touch and of course, your considered comments are welcome below.
This from Harry Eccles, a 31-year-old nurse living and working on the Isle of Wight, shares this Open Letter to Isle of Wight East Conservative MP, Joe Robertson. Ed
Hi Joe,
You know me, it’s the dreadlocked Green nurse in your constituency! We’ve spoken several times, and we always seem to have gotten on okay. Despite our clear political differences I have always found you fair and approachable, and we have often spoken about tackling issues that we both agree on and the best way forward.
I am writing this open letter to you following multiple posts on social media (mainly X) which I find deeply upsetting, and I wanted to take some time to explain why.
As you know I work as a nurse, but you might not know that alongside my main speciality of addiction, I also specialise in neurodiversity and will in fact be working full time as an ADHD Nurse practitioner in the new year. I have worked a lot with ADHD in the local drug and alcohol pathways as having ADHD is linked to a four times higher prevalence rate of addiction. Likewise, those with ADHD are five times more likely to suffer with anxiety or depression, whilst also being more likely than the non-ADHD population to have other neurodivergences such as autism. Likewise, people with ADHD are more likely to also have physical health complications such as diabetes or asthma. Moreover, increased suicidal ideation is also found amongst those with ADHD.
As you are aware, these are statistical findings on prevalence across a population, not defined pathways for any individual with ADHD. Many with ADHD will not have these other co-occurring conditions, but statistically, we know many more will.
Understanding disability
For many years, the discussion on disability has focused on the individual rather than the system. However, this is not the only way to look at it, we have to look at the relationship between the society and the individual who has a defined and lasting difference to most people.
For example, if a wheelchair user lives in a society with other wheelchair users, designed by wheelchair users, they would probably find society much less disabling than living in a society designed and built by non-wheelchair users. The same logic holds for ADHD.
Having ADHD in and of itself is not necessarily a disability. However, living in a high pressure society with multiple complex processes designed for neurotypical minds can be very disabling. Like many people with ADHD, I have continued paying phone bills for years after not having that phone any more (I was paying multiple at once) making me financially worse off, I have missed deadlines and got lost in what feels like endless paperwork, I have missed important meetings due to time blindness and I often collapse on my sofa at a weekend utterly overwhelmed and exhausted from simply navigating the world. I didn’t design the world this way, yet I am beholden to it. It can take more effort and time for the ADHD brain to keep up with these demands, and we may well need some extra support. That is before we consider any co-occurring conditions also being experienced which can compound these difficulties on a daily basis, making life very tricky for some.
ADHD can also mean that I think and create differently, and this is something that has helped me excel in certain jobs where my strategic out-of-the-box thinking has helped enormously. However, it is important to add, the benefit is only felt when I have a supportive boss and reasonable adjustments in place. That’s the point, it’s not the way our mind works in and of itself, it’s the relationship we have with others, with work and with society that shapes our experiences, and can help us to contribute, or leave us feeling isolated.
Understanding privilege
Now, you and I both have diagnosed ADHD. I was diagnosed at 28 after struggling with feelings of overwhelm and inadequacy when I was working full time as an NHS nurse. The process took me several years from start to finish, and I was referred by my GP to a private provider (funded by the NHS) after about 2-3 years when I received my diagnosis. I couldn’t afford to go private, as this was following 10 years of pay cuts from the Conservative government, and despite being a Nurse Specialist with advanced skills – I could never have even come close to affording a private assessment.
I understand that you recently paid for a private assessment, and I imagine that partly had something to do with the waiting lists for local assessments where we live. I understand that, however, the vast majority of your constituents do not have that privilege of a spare grand for a private diagnosis.
Likewise, you talk about growing up and not needing the ADHD diagnosis, but you also fail to mention that you went to the Island’s most prestigious private school, which again is a privileged start not many on the Island have. I also imagine in your role now as a shadow minister you have the support of admin and aides, and I imagine this is a huge help for you.
I myself recognise I am more privileged than many. I am a smart young white man, with a university degree. It is true that I have worked bloody hard to get where I am, but I can also recognise a degree of privilege there too. I have always been able to work full time with my ADHD, however, I have also been able to articulate and understand what reasonable adjustments I need and how to get them. I have also had several periods of ill health where I have completely collapsed due to ADHD-linked overwhelm. I have just about managed, with support, diagnosis, treatment and the benefit of my own nursing knowledge. Many people are less fortunate. They have fewer social resources to draw upon, they have other conditions to face, and they shouldn’t be made to feel guilty for asking for help.
You talk about your own experience, and that is your experience and is completely valid and true for you. However, that doesn’t make it someone else’s experience, and as an MP making important decisions I would ask you to think about the more vulnerable in your constituency, rather than your own privileged experience.
Welfare is a blessing, not a curse
I have worked with many incredible Island residents who have needed benefits to help get them through their recovery, get them back into meaningful contribution to society, and sometimes helped them simply survive when that was the best we could manage at the time. They are some of the brightest, most creative and intelligent people I know, but life has come at them hard. What they needed was help, understanding and support, not judgement.
As you know (though it is not clear from your X posts), many benefits are in fact ‘in-work’ benefits because of how hard austerity has shaken Britain. Your own government saw services cut to the bone, inflation soar and prices rocket meaning many people cannot survive on work alone. Many nurses even rely on benefit top-ups because they cannot support their families on their nursing salaries alone. Might I suggest that this be the real issue, one that you seem to conveniently ignore?
The Truth about ADHD and benefits
Finally, you keep ignoring the inconvenient truth that an ADHD diagnosis does not entitle you to benefits. You and I both have a diagnosis, but neither of us is entitled to benefits and rightly so as we do not need them. That is how the system works, it assesses need at specific moments in time. So why do you post as if this isn’t true?
You talk about a rocketing benefits bill, whilst ignoring that £30,000,000,000 was knocked off the economy overnight when Liz Truss made her disastrous budget, or that the Tories wasted £10,000,000,000 on PPE fraud during the CV-19 pandemic. Big numbers make for great headlines, but they lack the nuance needed to have a sensible discussion.
So what now?
Firstly you should focus on local NHS services and making sure people can actually get the treatment and care they need. The Tories cut the equivalent of £40,000,000,000 per year compared to European counterparts when in government – that makes £400,000,000,000 over the decade. We should invest in our local NHS mental health and ADHD services as a matter of priority.
Secondly, we should ask why work isn’t paying, and make sure that workers see a real and fair pay rise to enable them to support their families and also stimulate the local economy.
Finally, we should seek to educate ourselves on matters of disability and speak in an informed way that reduces stigma, not an ill-informed way which increases it.
Final thoughts
Joe, it is clear that I feel you have both misrepresented ADHD, disability and also benefits as a whole, and I hope you can recognise my experience in the subject matter and reflect on what I have said.
I would like to think we can retain our working relationship and discuss this further to see what we can do, because people out here are really suffering.
I would be happy to meet further to discuss how we could actually make things better for Island residents rather than worse, if this is something you would be up for doing.
Many thanks, Harry Eccles (Advanced Nurse Practitioner, your local constituent, and fellow ADHDer)



