Hundreds of disabled people on the Isle of Wight lost their benefits when they were reassessed for a new government payment, a move which campaigners have called a ‘scandal’.
The government is gradually replacing Disability Living Allowance (DLA) with Personal Independence Payment (PIP). These benefits help people pay for disability-related living costs, such as personal carers or mobility aids.
Controversial transition
The latest figures show 5,664 were receiving DLA in November 2017, as the old benefit is being phased out.
A further 4,424 people were receiving the Personal Independence Payment.
The transition has been controversial, as figures from the Department for Work and Pensions show 24% of people in Great Britain who received DLA failed to match the new criteria for PIP.
Stricter criteria means 100s lose benefit
On the Isle of Wight, 400 people receiving DLA had their benefits stopped when they reapplied for the new scheme between April 2013 and October 2017, 17% of all previous claimants. The criteria for PIP are stricter, and claims are reassessed on a more regular basis.
The assessment process, which is carried out by private contractors such as Capita, came under fire after a 2017 review revealed that 65% of those who challenged DWP decisions successfully had them overturned in court.
Rights campaigner: “PIP needs a fundamental redesign”
Ken Butler, welfare rights advisor at Disability Rights UK, said:
“The Government’s stated aim with PIP was to reduce the disability benefit expenditure by 20%, around £1.5 billion a year.
“It was designed to exclude many disabled people from getting help with the extra costs of their disability, including vital help with mobility. That around a quarter of disabled people have lost all their benefit entitlement is a scandal but no surprise.
“Unsurprisingly, many disabled people now have no confidence in the PIP reassessment process. Disability Rights UK want to see an in-house assessment process rather than one ruled by discredited private contractors, but PIP itself needs a fundamental redesign so it becomes a benefit to enable disabled people to lead full, active and independent lives.”
National picture
James Taylor, Head of Policy and Public Affairs at disability charity Scope, said:
“It’s alarming that natioally a quarter of DLA claimants have lost all support through the move to PIP.
“Scope analysis shows disabled people face extra costs of £570 a month on average.
“The hundreds of thousands of disabled people who have lost out on vital financial support didn’t suddenly see an end to these additional costs.
“Financial support helps to level the playing field between disabled people and non-disabled people, but the current assessment for PIP does not accurately reflect the extra costs disabled people face. It needs a radical overhaul, so it works for disabled people instead of against them.”
Article shared by Data Reporter, Niamh McIntyre, as part of the OnTheWight’s collaboration with Press Association and Urbs Media
Image: royblumenthal under CC BY 2.0
