Thumbs down sign - new
Image: striatic under CC BY 2.0

The Key points: Breaking down the report into ‘dysfunctional’ Isle of Wight Council 

If you don't want to read the 31-page report, OnTheWight has the highlights

OnTheWight has put together the key points made in the new independent governance report for those who don’t have the time or inclination to read it in full (embedded below for your convenience).

The report warns that Isle of Wight Council is “dysfunctional” and must urgently improve behaviour and decision-making or risk Government intervention – with external auditors already flagging “significant risks” that could trigger formal action.

A former council CEO
Richard Penn, a former council chief executive with decades of experience investigating failing authorities, was commissioned to examine councillor behaviour, relations between councillors and officers, and whether decision-making is working as it should.

Mr Penn found that disruptive behaviour from a “small number” of councillors is having a much wider impact on the organisation, officer morale and public perception – but warns this is merely a symptom of deeper problems.

Leaders of Isle of Wight Council political groups have responded to the report today (Tuesday), saying they are glad that it has been produced and that the issues it addresses are recognised and highlighted.

A symptom, not the cause
Mr Penn’s review says the council’s issues go far beyond isolated incidents in meetings. He states,

“Inappropriate member behaviour is a symptom of broader organisational dysfunctionality rather than a cause.”

He continues:

“The reality is that the council is dysfunctional and has been for several years.”

The report notes that officers are sometimes criticised publicly, including in meetings and on social media. Some councillors told Mr Penn they believe officer decisions are delayed or ignored, while officers reported feeling undermined or reluctant to attend meetings.

Mr Penn also highlights that most councillors remain silent when behaviour breaches the Code of Conduct,

“Most councillors do not call out the bad behaviour at the point at which it happens.”

Examples recorded in the report include,

“There is abhorrent behaviour to others and each other.”

and

“Officers are stated as not being competent by people who do not get their own way.”

One councillor remarked,

“If I were an officer I would have left.”

Another observation captured by Mr Penn,

“There appears to be a silent and hidden barrier between officers and councillors.”

External auditors raise alarm
The report reveals that the council’s external auditors, Ernst & Young, have identified governance as a “serious risk” and are conducting a specific review.

The auditors state there are risks to the council including:

  • Being placed in a position to incur potential or actual financial loss
  • Employment relationships with staff including the potential for service disruption
  • Reputational damage

Mr Penn warns that the auditors’ concerns could result in a qualified Value for Money judgement, which would have serious consequences. The auditors have powers to issue:

  • Statutory Recommendations under the Local Audit and Accountability Act 2014, which must be considered by Full Council and are routinely reported to Government
  • Public Interest Reports, which would trigger Government scrutiny and could lead to Best Value intervention

The cost of preparing such reports would fall on the council.

Recent decision-making failures
Mr Penn attended a recent Full Council meeting where two major policy issues – Pension Fund pooling and Local Government Reorganisation – were debated.

Despite officer recommendations and administration support, both reports failed to achieve agreed positions. The report states,

“The Council currently does not have an agreed position on either of these matters.”

This is presented as a concrete example of how dysfunction is preventing the council from progressing critical business.

The report also cites an example where the Pensions Committee decided in June to consult more than 30 bodies about Pension Fund pooling. Four months later, Mr Penn was told that not one of these bodies had been consulted.

Structural governance problems
Beyond behaviour, Mr Penn identifies serious structural weaknesses in the council’s governance arrangements:

Key officers unavailable or part-time
The council’s Monitoring Officer was on long-term sick leave until very recently – a critical absence given this officer’s role in managing member behaviour and ethical governance.

The council’s s151 Officer (the chief finance officer) is part-time and based on the mainland, where he also works for another local authority.

Mr Penn questions whether this is appropriate,

“It is a matter of concern… that the Council’s designated s151 Officer is not a full-time officer of the Council, given the urgent need for improved governance.”

No effective standards process
The report reveals there is no dedicated Standards Committee at the council. The current system relies entirely on the Monitoring Officer’s discretion, with the Appeals Committee structure apparently never having dealt formally with a complaint against an Isle of Wight councillor.

Mr Penn describes this as “totally unsatisfactory” and calls for it to be addressed urgently.

Committee system not working
There is a “consistent view from officers and members that the new Committee system is not delivering the anticipated benefits,” with a “lack of clarity of direction, focus and understanding”.

The council moved to a committee system in May 2025 but is now likely to return to a Leader/Cabinet model following proposed legislative changes.

Working from home hampering relationships
The council’s work-from-home policy means members and officers rarely meet in person. One member described County Hall on Fridays as “like the Marie Celeste”.

Mr Penn notes this does not help build positive working relationships.

Poor member induction
One councillor told Mr Penn their induction consisted of being “given a laptop and a tour of County Hall and was then told to ‘get on with it’.”

Multiple members commented on the inadequacy of induction and ongoing support, which has been reduced due to austerity pressures.

Government already watching
The report reveals that the Government has already written to the council, expressing concern after watching the 17th September 2025 council meeting online (see below).

The letter, dated 16th October 2025, from the Deputy Director of Local Government Stewardship and Interventions at the Ministry for Housing, Communities and Local Government, states:

“We observed the council meeting on the 17th September 2025 and were concerned about some of the behaviours we saw.”

The letter reminds the council of best value principles including:

  • Constructive relationships between members and officers
  • A culture of cooperation, respect and trust
  • Civil working relationships between Group Leaders

The Government makes clear it will “continue to actively monitor progress” over the next 12 months.

Crucially, the letter warns,

“This letter is not a best value notice… but signals that without additional assurance the department may decide to take further action.”

Mr Penn responds,

“This is a stark warning that the Government has serious concerns about member/officer relationships and relationships with stakeholders as well as about member behaviour at the Council.”

What is a Best Value intervention?
Councils must demonstrate they use public money efficiently and are well governed under the Best Value duty.

If a council is not meeting these standards, Government can send inspectors to carry out a Best Value Inspection.

If problems are confirmed, the Government can:

  • Issue formal directions
  • Require external oversight
  • Impose Commissioners to take over decision-making

Commissioners have the power to override councillors and run areas of the authority until improvement is proven. Recent examples in England include Croydon, Nottingham and Tower Hamlets.

Behaviour must change
Mr Penn notes that Isle of Wight Council is at risk of the same outcome if behaviour does not change,

“The stakes are high, and the potential for government intervention is a reality. It would only take a significant event… for the Government to conclude that there is no option but to initiate a Best Value inspection with the inevitable outcome of formal intervention with the associated costs and organisational disruption for at least two years.”

Recommendations
Mr Penn makes several urgent recommendations, including:

Immediate actions

  • Strict enforcement of the Councillors’ Code of Conduct at every meeting
  • Chairs must read a script at the start of meetings reminding members of conduct requirements
  • Written guidance on Points of Order to be placed at each member’s position
  • Any breach to be challenged immediately by those present – not left to the Chair alone
  • Group leaders to meet with the Council Chair before Full Council meetings

Strengthening governance structures

  • Re-establish a Standards Committee with real consequences for breaches
  • The proposed restructure should elevate the Monitoring Officer to Strategic Director level
  • Consider making the s151 Officer a full-time council employee
  • Review the entire standards complaints process using best practice from other councils

Supporting members and officers

  • Comprehensive induction programme for members elected in May 2026
  • Enhanced ongoing training and support for councillors (potentially funded by LGA/MHCLG)
  • Training for all officers on working with elected members
  • Earlier involvement of councillors in policy development, not just decision-making
  • Consider all councillors sharing common space at County Hall rather than separate Group rooms

Cultural change
Mr Penn emphasises,

“Inappropriate member behaviour either towards other councillors or towards council officers must be widely seen as unacceptable, and respect between members and officers must be reinstated.”

He adds:

“Things have to change fundamentally, and change quickly, if the potential for formal intervention is to be successfully avoided.”

The report
You can read the report in full, embedded below for your convenience.

Subscribe
Email updates?
13 Comments
oldest
newest most voted