£7,800 Fine For Isle of Wight Food Firm

Some pretty large fines for Island food firm. This just in from the Council. Ed

A food supplier based on the Isle of Wight has been fined almost £8,000 and ordered to pay costs of over £1,400 for breaching the food hygiene regulations.

The owner of Hamilton’s Fine Foods, Robin Anderson Gustar, pleaded guilty to six food hygiene offences at a hearing in Newport (IOW) Magistrates Court on Tuesday 24 August.

Of the offences, two related to failing to protect food from contamination, two were for failing to have sufficient controls in place during the production and distribution of food, one was for an unclean premises and one was for failing to adequately train and supervise staff.

The charges were brought following routine hygiene inspections carried out by IW Council’s Environmental Health Team on 4 November 2009 at Hamilton’s Fine Foods shop in Wootton and a visit to its Cowes shop on 10 December 2009.

Hefty fines
Robin Gustar of Hamilton’s Fine Foods was fined £1,300 for each offence – £7,800 in total – and ordered to pay IW Council costs of £1,422 and a £15 victim surcharge.

Isle of Wight Council’s Environmental Health Manager, Amanda Gregory said: “Food companies on the Isle of Wight have a duty to ensure they maintain high standards of hygiene, whether that be on the shop floor or during the preparation and distribution of food.

“They also have a duty to ensure their staff are well trained and supervised. This successful prosecution demonstrates we will take legal action against any firm who we feel is not maintaining these standards”

Following the hygiene offences being identified, immediate action was taken by the business to address the concerns. Both premises now meet the hygiene standards required in relation to the areas that were the subject of the prosecution.

Wootton and Cowes premises only
The prosecution is only in relation to Hamilton’s Fine Foods outlets in Wootton and Cowes and did not involve the firm’s other premises across the Island.

Robin Gustar was represented by Keith Verrinder of Roach Pittis Solicitors.

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
15 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
wabbit
26, August 2010 10:29 am

When a company or individual gets a large fine like this,where does money go?Is it possible to see how it is spent after the fine is paid?

Don Smith
Reply to  wabbit
27, August 2010 12:41 pm

Councillors expenses and perks.

Most of this stuff comes from the mainland – We have no abattoirs on the IoW.

Noraa
26, August 2010 10:31 am

not so fine foods then. also can’t stand the blokes voice on the radio ads.

BigEars
Reply to  Noraa
26, August 2010 11:42 am

Well that’s it then. I didn’t mind the health and safety breaches, but an annoying voice on the ad? I’ll never cross their threshold again.

Margie
Reply to  Noraa
26, August 2010 11:48 am

I have no problem with his voice, but found his pronunciation of buffet (buff-it) puzzling. You’d think whoever recorded it would tell him.

The fines seem very steep. Especially as it says that they made changes immediately after the inspection. Wonder if they’d already had a warning?

Fay W
26, August 2010 11:47 am

And that’s why – even though I live near-enough opposite Hamiltons in Wootton, I will always go to Martindales’ butchers in Ryde :D

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  Fay W
26, August 2010 11:49 am

VB news is ‘really’ hyperlocal for you today then Fay ;-)

Fay W
Reply to  Sally Perry
26, August 2010 12:07 pm

Lol, it’s like you’re stalking me :D

Brian
26, August 2010 2:47 pm

I once used the Ryde branch of Hamiltons [now closed] just to see what they were like. I recall that I felt hygiene there was not quite up to the standard I had expected from such a well-advertised firm. Naturally, their door was never darkened by me again. Like Fay, I also go to Martindales, almost as much for the jolly banter with Des as for the… Read more »

wabbit
26, August 2010 6:29 pm

I wonder if Medina have put in a quick bid!!!!

Shobba
26, August 2010 6:51 pm

I’ve used Hamilton’s for years without problem. They are a very hard working family – a proper local business, who seem to have slipped up at two of their branches. It does seem an enormous fine for a small local firm, bearing in mind the fines we see dished out weekly to muggers, stabbers, drunks and vandals. As ever, the punishment never seems to fit the crime… Read more »

Chris
Reply to  Shobba
27, August 2010 10:49 am

If you dont know what they did wrong, how can you possibly know if it was too harsh? Since when were middle class families above the law? Lets be absolutely clear here – the rules are the same for EVERYBODY, because the dangers caused by poor hygiene couldnt care less for social status. If a business doesnt abide by the rules and risks the health of its… Read more »

intentionally blank
Reply to  Chris
27, August 2010 1:43 pm

well said. maybe worth adding that just as the rules are the same for everyone, so are the punishments the same for everyone. I agree that fines for muggers, vandals etc are a joke and that more should be done to deal with that sort of crime, but that doesnt mean that less should be done to deal with poor hygine. It also stikes me that there… Read more »

Chris
Reply to  intentionally blank
27, August 2010 8:10 pm

Shobba, look at the details in the CP – they are lucky they didnt kill anyone. Putting people’s health and potentially their lives at risk for a few extra quid, and then not rectifying the situation when warned, is inexcusable.

Towel
27, August 2010 9:50 am

So glad I don’t eat meat.

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined