St George's Way Newport

ASDA planning application: Planning Committee make their decision

Members of the Isle of Wight Planning Committee have been discussing and deliberating two separate planning applications for the last four+ hours.

They are alternate plans for an out of town supermarket; one on land occupied by Newport Football Club and the other on land next to it.

ASDA originally submitted their plans in December 2012 and alternative plans were revealed by South Coast Leisure, the owners of Newport Football Ground, in July 2013.

Both applications were recommended for conditional planning permission by planning officers. Both sites would offer petrol stations and ample parking.

Several members of the Planning Committee expressed their concern about the schemes, claiming they could have a detrimental effect on smaller businesses in Newport.

When the decision came to a vote, both application were approved by the Planning Committee.

Papers are embedded below for your convenience


Image: © Google Streetview

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
15 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Asite2c
28, February 2012 10:48 am

An excellent alternative to the rag bag of a budget which will be proposed by the Tories. Sadly, instead of supporting theses proposals which could benefit the Island, the Tory members will just tow the party line and give the Indedependents proposals short shrift, just as they do with expert advice, opposing ideas and the concerns of the Island people.

Cllr Geoff Lumley (Labour)
28, February 2012 3:00 pm

The email I have just sent to Ian Stephens: Dear Ian Just to say that I will be voting for the Independent Group’s budget alternative tomorrow evening after mine has been dispensed with by the Tories. There are a few elements of it that I don’t agree with – I doubt you can save that much with a car park permit, we don’t have the in-house capacity… Read more »

Steephill Jack
Reply to  Cllr Geoff Lumley (Labour)
28, February 2012 9:39 pm

Well said Geoff: you have done your homework too. Now is the time to free yourself from the Labour Party and become an Independent. Your majority will increase, I’m sure.

Geoff Lumley
Reply to  Steephill Jack
29, February 2012 6:49 am

Thanks Jack – but don’t be daft ! Have you seen the increase in my vote last time? Up 17%…..and I did that by being a man of principle. A LABOUR man.

Steephill Jack
Reply to  Geoff Lumley
29, February 2012 7:43 am

Your vote went up because you are known to be a good, reliable councillor. Without the Labour tag you would get even more votes.
Independent councillors can also be men of principle.

island wide
28, February 2012 4:21 pm

Following proposals from different parties concerning the budget I note that one news media source is stating that Leader of the Council David Pugh has said that the Independents have left it too late with their proposals. He allegedly said that although alternative proposals are welcome the lateness of the publication makes it difficult to consider them in advance of the meeting tomorrow. I wonder why the… Read more »

Asite2c
Reply to  island wide
28, February 2012 4:59 pm

Due to a lack of political education, perhaps Pugh confuses dictatorship with democracy and is unable to distinguish the two?

john
28, February 2012 8:26 pm

Sounds really good, apart from not refurbishing the toilets, in fact, too good to be true? Still, they know they’re never going to have to deliver it so they can promise the earth. However, the public will be fooled.

Chris Welsford
Reply to  john
29, February 2012 7:52 am

With only a year or so until elections, we would hardly risk making proposals that cannot be implemented. In 2013 we may have to put our money where our mouth is. We consulted carefully with finance officers and obtained the necessary guidance, which we followed. We have made sure that our proposals are deliverable and given the opportunity, we would be able to deliver them. It is… Read more »

Michael W
Reply to  Chris Welsford
29, February 2012 7:56 am

Well said Chris!

Jonathan Bacon
28, February 2012 9:02 pm

There’s no point publishing an unworkable budget. We have worked hard to create a legal balanced alternative budget – agreed as such by the relevant senior council officers – to show that things can be done better than they are at the moment.

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined