Charlie Urry - cascade broken up-width-1200px

Concerns over sewer collapse and water waste flooding raised at Scrutiny Committee

Very serious concerns of sewer collapse and flooding in the water waste system at Sandown have been raised.

It is the only Isle of Wight treatment plant branded as a high level of concern by Southern Water in its baseline risk and vulnerability assessment.

The water company, however, say those problems could be fixed if surface water run-off was dealt with differently, enabling it to eliminate water discharges into the Solent.

Hydraulic overload of public sewers
As reported by News OnTheWight at Tuesday’s Corporate Scrutiny Committee (catch up here), Southern Water’s area manager Keith Herbert, gave an overview of its position after recent flooding devastated properties across the Island.

Hydraulic overload of the public sewers — or too much water in the system — was found to be a ‘not so hypothetical scenario’, said Mr Herbert.

He said the flooding that occurred was a problem shared among agencies, including the Isle of Wight Council and the Environmental Agency.

Mr Herbert said the current system was not the way water should be managed and agencies should be thinking about what should be done instead.

Concerns about Sandown treatment works
Cllr Peter Spink highlighted the six very significant concerns at the Sandown treatment works, which he said was considered to be the Island’s flagship plant, and has a forecasted growth increase of 25 per cent by 2050.

The six serious concerns were risks of pollution, sewer collapse and flooding, storm overflow, dry weather flow compliance and nutrient neutrality.

Herbert: £9m on ‘proactive intervention’
Mr Herbert said as part of its £50m plans for the Island in the next 40 years, £9m would be used to address some of those concerns as ‘proactive intervention’.

He said,

“A lot of those problems would be resolved by removing surface water connections from the public foul sewer.

“If surface water connections were not plumbed into the foul sewer we would not flood as much and we would not discharge. It is fair to say we could eliminate almost all discharges by removing that surface water runoff.”

Separate surface and foul water
One recommendation was to completely separate surface and foul water, as surface water could overwhelm the capacity of public foul sewers.

The company is working towards a full rationalisation of water supplies on the Island as 20 works and 30 reservoirs serve the population, which Mr Herbert described as too elaborate.

He said things could be made a lot more simple.

New properties not the problem
When questioned about whether new developments and more housing would add to the pressures, Mr Herbert said newer properties were more water-efficient with older housing stock causing more problems.

Meetings between Southern Water, the council’s cabinet and Isle of Wight Conservative MP, Bob Seely have looked at ways forward to fix problems.

Jarman: It’s a no brainer
Cllr Chris Jarman said one of the outcomes was that future developments would need to have complete separation of sewage from surface water.

He said it made sound environmental sense and was a no brainer, that at the same time they go back and fix the existing infrastructure.

The water company is developing a drainage and wastewater management plan to ensure the sustainability of the infrastructure so customers’ needs are met and the environment protected.​

This article is from the BBC’s LDRS (Local Democracy Reporter Service) scheme, which News OnTheWight is part of. Read here to find about more about how that scheme works on the Island. Some alterations and additions may have been made by News OnTheWight. Ed

Image: © Charlie Urry