Council Workers Paid Through Limited Companies On Radio 4 Tonight

The BBC’s investigative radio programme, File on 4, will tonight report on its findings about senior council officials being paid through Limited companies, a la Dave Burbage Consulting Ltd at Isle of Wight council.

Tax Return FormThe BBC have sent Freedom of Information (FoI) requests to 400 councils across the UK, discovering that “Almost 100 permanent posts at local councils are being filled by people paid through limited companies.”

They also have found that “dozens of high-earners are allowed to make their own tax arrangements rather than be paid through the PAYE system.”

“It’s not right” says Margaret Hodge
Margaret Hodge, the chair of the House of Commons Public Accounts Committee, told the programme that her committee would pursue the issue – “Where you are a public servant it’s not right you should be paid in a way that avoids tax. If someone sets up a scheme to avoid paying tax, that is income foregone to the public purse.”

In a 1,700+ word statement about Dave Burbage and his Limited Company, the Chief Executive of the Isle of Wight council, Steve Beynon, said “Dave meets all of his tax obligations.”

The programme is on BBC Radio4 tonight (Tuesday) at 8pm and Sunday, 18 March at 5pm.

Update: Embedded the podcast. [audio:http://downloads.bbc.co.uk/podcasts/radio4/fileon4/fileon4_20120313-2100a.mp3]

Source

Image: Tax Brackets under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
11 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Stephen
13, March 2012 10:07 am

There is succinct explanation of the financial benefits of and to employees working as service companies in local and national government on Page 32 – last article – of the latest Private Eye.

Has the District Auditor ever voiced any comments about statutory posts in IWC being taken by non-employees?

Thomas C.
13, March 2012 10:25 am

If this is shut down in the public sector, it will open up a much wider discussion about contractors working for private companies, of which there must be many thousands out there.

Income tax evasion is income tax evasion (or ‘efficiency’ if you’d rather) whether it’s public or private sector.

Stephen
Reply to  Thomas C.
13, March 2012 1:35 pm

Is this where HMRC’s IR35 regime kicks in? One tax advisory website for the self-employed suggests that HMRC will consider factors including:· What is the client’s business? Is there a written contract in place, and what is the length? What are the terms of the contract – e.g. does the contractor have a notice period, the hours of work, where and how is the work carried out?… Read more »

allan
13, March 2012 10:50 am

the Chief Executive of the Isle of Wight council, Steve Beynon, said “Dave meets all of his tax obligations.”
well that is probably very true under his present contract ,still not morally right

Asite2c
Reply to  allan
13, March 2012 2:46 pm

In my opinion, Benyon had no option but to make excuses and support the scandal of hiring limited companies. As Chief Executive, he probably gave the “go ahead” to employ them.

This Tory council gives me the impression of running County Hall like a dodgy big business instead as a democratic local council working for the Island people.

Leonard
13, March 2012 2:33 pm

For those interested, please see: http://www.bbc.co.uk/news/uk-politics-17339374

Tax advisor
13, March 2012 5:48 pm

Doing this saves tax. If not, why bother? This council has colluded in a very dodgy avoidance scheme to allow less tax to be paid than a direct employee would pay. They never answered the how much extra pension does he collect from his old employer question either. It stinks, the government needs to say enough is enough. Pugh and Beynon should both be sacked for allowing… Read more »

witchfinder general
Reply to  Tax advisor
13, March 2012 8:10 pm

It is not about saving taxes, it is a pension scam. You cannot draw a council pension if you work for any local authority. But you can take early retirement then work for a council as a consultant working for your own limited company. Burbage retired early. Benyon will do the same when he retires after the next elections, though it is doubtful that he has many… Read more »

Stephen
Reply to  witchfinder general
14, March 2012 5:08 pm

Not strictly true.

My understanding of the rules, as set out by the London Pensions Fund Authority, is that someone in receipt of a local government pension may return to local government work & keep their pension income plus a new salary as long as the total income does NOT exceed their income at the time of retirement with cost of living increases factored in.

Matthew James Martin
15, December 2012 9:31 am

Within what has come to light of Central Government antics in recent years, this is why I have already told others that if I am successful in gaining the Cowes Medina Ward from the Conservatives, any Island resident can have full access, barring security details, to my financial records. I understand how distressed the public are within hearing how their taxes are being used at times. I… Read more »

BRIAN
15, December 2012 11:34 am

The Inland Revenue have a pithy saying: “Those who pay tax are on PAYE, those who chose not to pay tax (the self-employed) are on PIYL – Pay If You Like. I have never understood why successive governments have tolerated separate rules for the normal employee and the self- employed. An example: I work for an employer, my next door neighbour is a self-employed plumber. His first… Read more »