Isle of Wight fire stations ‘below standard’ of mainland due to lack of direct investment, report reveals

Much of the meeting was held in private, but not before it was revealed that due to lack of direct investment, the physical condition of Isle of Wight fire stations are considerably below the standard of those on the mainland

Newport fire station showers

Lack of investment in fire stations on the Isle of Wight has meant the buildings are considerably below the standards of those in Hampshire.

Part of a report was read out in a public meeting of the Hampshire and Isle of Wight Fire and Rescue shadow authority, revealing the state of the Island’s fire stations — a view the Fire Brigades’ Union agrees with.

Rest of meeting excluded of press and public
Councillors from both the Isle of Wight Council and Hampshire County Council did not comment and eventually held the rest of the meeting in private session, discussing improvements to the fire stations managed by the new Combined Fire Authority (CFA).

The CFA, a coming together of the Island’s and Hampshire’s fire and rescue services, is acting as a shadow form until April 2021 when it will take force.

Justifying the private meeting
At the meeting, in a debate as to whether the councillors should head into private session, Hampshire’s Cllr Jonathan Glen explained why the report should be heard in private by reading, in public session, two points that highlighted the poor physical conditions of the Island’s fire buildings.

He said:

“The [buildings] physical conditions are considerably below the standard of those on the mainland.

“This lack of direct investment over several years has led to a reduction in the standard of the physical built environment for which the fire service operates.”

Stewart: Voted for rest of report to be heard in private
Cllr Dave Stewart, leader of the Isle of Wight Council, who attended the meeting, voted for the rest of the report to be heard in private but said he thought the information should be made public as soon as possible.

Speaking after the meeting, Cllr Stewart said the operational response of both Hampshire and Isle of Wight firefighters had not been impacted by the issues with the Island’s fire stations.

A wide-ranging station investment programme will start under the new CFA, which Cllr Stewart says the Island will benefit from.

Cllr Stewart said:

“While Hampshire does have some newer, comparatively modern stations, such as Basingstoke which opened in 2018, it also has others which are more than 60 years old and scheduled to be rebuilt.

“The IWFRS has prioritised its investments over recent years in state-of-the- art fire engines, specialist equipment which Hampshire has since adopted and personal protective equipment.”

Cave: Service not been properly funded for at least two decades
Spencer Cave, the Isle of Wight’s Brigade Secretary for the FBU, said while he agreed appliances and specialist equipment had been invested in, with a new fire engine bought in 2017, the resources were committed to the service under the previous administration and not the current Conservative ruling party.

Mr Cave argued the fire and rescue service has not been properly funded for at least two decades, with some projects not getting past the planning stage, promises falling flat or only parts of stations getting upgraded but causing multiple issues.

Poor quality of work
Newport Fire Station (pictured above) has had the shower area refurbished. Mr Cave said the work cost in excess of £26,000 which has had to be revisited at least three times due to leaks and the poor quality of flooring.

Mr Cave said:

“We understand central government has cut the cash to local councils under its austerity lie and the council has very little resources, but it does waste so much money using one approved contractor.

“Retained duty system (RDS) stations have had very little expenditure — Bembridge has had a leaking roof for at least ten years, that is a health and safety hazard. East Cowes also has a leaking roof.

“The facilities on the RDS stations are not acceptable for a modern service and are like stepping back into the sixties.

“The current council has spent very little since the CFA was announced, knowing the burden would be taken from them. The CFA has said it will spend money on the estates, but we shall wait and see.”

In public consultation documents about the idea of a CFA, it was said the current fire stations would require £2.3 million to keep the estate a safe place to work back in 2018.

This article is from the BBC’s LDRS (Local Democracy Reporter Service) scheme, which OnTheWight is taking part in. Some alterations and additions may be been made by OnTheWight. Ed

Tuesday, 20th October, 2020 6:13pm



Filed under: Fire, Island-wide, Isle of Wight News, LDRS, Top story

Any views or opinions presented in the comments below must comply with the Commenting 'House Rules' and are solely those of the author and do not represent those of OnTheWight.

Leave your Reply

4 Comments on "Isle of Wight fire stations ‘below standard’ of mainland due to lack of direct investment, report reveals"

newest oldest most voted

Each station should have proper individual showers, wc cubicles with washbasins in them, decent rest facilities, a good kitchen, and washing & drying machines.


Did I read that right…our glorious leader voted for the “rest of the meeting to be held in private”. Why was that then? Shame, embarrassment, guilt, concern about his position in the upcoming elections. It would be interesting to know.


Your open and honest council. Wanting to hold meetings in private because it all is a bit embarrassing. These meetings need to be held in public so that all can see the shambolic way in which the fire service has been treated.


Maybe they have received a writ