Plans for four ‘low-cost’ homes on land currently used as a garden in an Isle of Wight town are facing opposition from neighbours.
Overdevelopment, overlooking, a Japanese Knotweed ‘infestation’ and highway safety are among the concerns raised with Penny Downer’s application to build two pairs of semi-detached chalet bungalows at 109 Old Road in East Cowes.
The proposal includes parking and the formation of a vehicle access off Oaks Close.
Benefits in providing low-cost housing within an underused urban plot of land clearly outweigh any possible identified harm, Ms Downer’s agent, Paul Stack, previously said.
Overlooking fears
East Cowes resident Richard White said,
“My home, specifically two primary bedrooms and family bathroom, would be overlooked by four new units, through 12 or more windows, by 18-20 people.
“This is a significant material change from not being overlooked at all. The associated noise and disturbance from these units, vehicles and the subsequent loss of outlook will undoubtedly have a negative effect on me and my family.”
Concerns over Oaks Close access
Another neighbour, Karen Sunderland, said she has ‘serious concerns’ over whether the adjacent Oaks Close is an appropriate access route.
She said the residential road is relatively narrow and already presents difficulties for larger vehicles.
Japanese knotweed on the site
Referring to Japanese Knotweed on the site, Gregory Wilson said,
“Whilst being sprayed, keeping down the vegetation above ground, it will only be a matter of time before it grows again, and has the capability to grow through concrete.”
Mr White claimed the application has not adequately addressed the confirmed infestation.
Agent’s case for the scheme
Paul Stack previously said,
“The minor and sympathetic scale of the redevelopment ensure that the proposed works will not impact on the amenities of any nearby residential occupiers.
“Advice received from Island Roads following a pre-application request was generally supportive of the highway aspects of the scheme.”
The town planner said a preliminary ecological assessment has been carried out which notes the presence of Japanese Knotweed will require management strategy for its removal and eradication.
View the plans
Members of the public can comment on the plans (26/01099/FUL) until 21st September and a decision is expected by 13th October 2026.
This article is from the BBC’s LDRS (Local Democracy Reporter Service) scheme, which News OnTheWight is taking part in. Some alterations and additions may have been made by OnTheWight. Ed
