U Turn in the snow

Cabinet member u-turns on information given to the press

Last November OnTheWight ran an article about a report in the County Press.

It said that a CP reporter had incorrectly stated a decision to scrap the sale of the Blackgang Viewpoint car park had been made in private and Cllr Jon Gilbey had been mis-quoted following the November Cabinet meeting.

The basis for our article was information directly provided to OnTheWight by Cllr Gilbey. He’d told us in no uncertain terms that the decision had not been made in private and that he’d been mis-quoted by the CP reporter. He went so far as to point out the specific words the reporter had got wrong in their article.

Contacted by the CP
The article had only been live for a short time before the CP contacted OnTheWight. This marked the start of a great deal of time being spent trying to get to the bottom of this.

During this Cllr Gilbey did a complete about-face and, despite stating categorically to OnTheWight that the situation had been misinterpreted by the CP reporter, he then chose to support the CP version of what he’d said.

Apology
As readers know, OnTheWight works hard to not publish incorrect information.

We wrote the article on good faith, but on this occasion, through no fault of our own, some of what you may have read in that article wasn’t correct, so we wanted to take the opportunity of readdressing that.

We’ve already spoken to the reporter directly about this, but we’d like to take this opportunity to apologise for our mistake of believing the word of that Cabinet member over the reporter.

That, it turns out to our great surprise, was a mistake. One we certainly won’t repeating again in the future.

Image: patrickkiteley under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
10 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
P Wilkins
12, February 2013 10:09 am

Is this the first time that these exams that ‘were the reason for the delay’ have happened at this time of year? If not, wouldn’t you have thought that they would have factored this necessary break into the original project plans … unless those doing the planning, or those overseeing it and signed it off were, yet again, not performing their roles to what many people might… Read more »

Don Smith
Reply to  P Wilkins
18, February 2013 7:04 pm

Will this delay at the Medina cause disruption
to the IoW festival? Where will the VIPs and the performers take a shower and park their vehicles?

I am informed that the alteration and up-grading of the pool, etceteras will not be completed until the end of June 2013. Or have I been misinformed?

Billy Builder
12, February 2013 10:35 am

This sounds like a significant time overrun on a project that cannot have been scheduled to take much more than 6 weeks for phase one. I take it that [part of comment removed by moderator] will be suspended pending investigation following this 50% (guessed) increase in project delivery. On a similar note, can we have an update as the the status of the suspended officers following the… Read more »

Martin Stones
Reply to  Billy Builder
12, February 2013 11:54 am

I would think that it would be highly unlikely that [part of comment removed by moderator] would be either suspended or sacked for this or any other failing, as he is part of the inner clique or rat pack that control the Council. [part of comment removed by moderator]

Martin Stones
Reply to  Martin Stones
12, February 2013 5:49 pm

I’m a little bit surprised that this comment has been moderated, as the person named was the person from the Council making the quote within the article. It is a very sad state of affairs if we cannot give our opinion on an article.

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  Martin Stones
12, February 2013 8:52 pm

Your comment and the one you were replying to (by Billy Builder) were both reported to us as potentially defamatory and damaging to the named officers. We immediately suspended the comments pending review and after seeking a legal opinion re-approved the comments with the necessary moderation.

Angela Rann
Reply to  Billy Builder
12, February 2013 7:43 pm

17.Dec.2012 5:01pm Is it now fashionable to be late or is it just the council? Every press release lately from the council mentions delays. If there was other pools and gyms in Newport then perhaps they would get things finished faster! Nothing changes does it? As I mentioned in December last year, late is the new on-time. Foot-in-mouth press release though by Mr M. ‘Scale of the… Read more »

Angela Rann
Reply to  Angela Rann
14, February 2013 8:17 pm

These press releases are now becoming a daily and growth industry for IW Council. Who is actually in charge of these projects and why is every delay unforeseen, not anticipated, not as expected. It really is stretching the use of language and press statements about our ‘customers’ and ‘keeping them informed’ about ‘slight delays’ – Yawn, yawn. Either the council knows what it is doing or it… Read more »

alex davies
Reply to  Billy Builder
14, February 2013 3:12 pm

Hey Billy,

Have you noticed that the Crematorium has now been delayed by three months due no doubt to the incompetent project management of the Deputy Director of the Environment. Mind you base on your earlier posting perhaps Stuart Love should take the hit

Sciolist
Reply to  alex davies
14, February 2013 3:30 pm

So, Cowes High is just the tip of the council’s construction incompetence iceberg? (Iceberg being the appropriate object for our Titanic council.)

Didn’t The Heights over-run badly too? Now we hear the crematorium is forcing delays and disruption on to Island families. You can’t even get a cremation without these clowns messing it up.

Does anyone remember a building project delivered on time or on budget?

matt.h
12, February 2013 11:32 am

Regarding the Cowes fiasco and the suspension of the two officers, are these people still suspended, if so, why? It must be at least 3 months since these individuals were suspended on full pay, surely the Council has been able to investigate this by now. If these people are guilty of gross misconduct, gross negligence, rodgering the CEO’s daughter, or what ever offence they are charged with,… Read more »

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined