Electric car being charged on street

Colin Palmer’s take on the Isle of Wight EV charging plans and the state of the EV market

With the Alliance at County Hall seemingly getting stuck into building the Electric Vehicle (EV) charging infrastructure on the Isle of Wight, News OnTheWight approached Colin Palmer (founder of Wight Community Energy) to ask him if he’d take a look over what’s being proposed. 

Happily he accepted and has not only done that, but has called on his long working experience in renewable energy and lays out the current state of the EV market, where EV charging currently is and outlines where he thinks it and the Island will be going. Ed


The world is shifting to electric powered vehicles at an ever accelerating rate, with many countries planning to stop the sale of fossil fuelled cars in the coming decade.

In the UK, the sale of new fossil fuelled cars will be banned from 2030, just eight years away.

Car buyers are starting to get the message
According to the SMMT, “more new battery electric vehicles (BEVs) were registered in 2021 than over the previous five years combined.

In December 2021, 25 per cent of all new cars sold in the UK were electric. In total, almost 200,000 battery electric vehicles were sold last year, and this number is expected to increase to more than 300,000 in 2022, taking the total fleet to more than 700,000.

How to charge all these new EVs
With so many EVs coming onto the roads, how will they all be charged? Where will all the charge points be?

Norway leads the world in the adoption of EVs – with more than 300,000 BEVs registered to date, for a population of around 5.5million people. To charge these vehicles, Norway has 20,000 public charge points, so around 15 cars per charge point.

In the UK we have almost 30,000 public charge points for around 400,000 BEVs; about 13 cars per charge point, placing us slightly ahead of Norway. At a national level we are doing pretty well.

IW nowhere near national standards
But here on the Isle of Wight, the charger availability is not up to national standards. According to Zap-Map, which shows all the charging points, there are only four chargers in public car parks, with a few more in locations like Ventnor Botanic Gardens and Morrisons – so being charitable there are maybe ten that are readily accessible.

There are no on-street chargers and not one conventional service station is listed, but seven retail outlets do have chargers. In all, there may be twenty chargers that are available for public use.

We have more than 70,000 light vehicles on the Island (and many more in the summer), so even if only 2 per cent of them are plug-ins, to be in line with the national average we need at least 100 charge points. Way to go!

Extra chargers planned
Against this background, the Council’s announcement that it is joining forces with Joju/Mer to install new chargers in nine locations (and replace five existing, but unreliable chargers) is to be welcomed.

This will bring the total number of public charge connections up to 28 – not the 100 required to reach the national average, but a big step in that direction.

Unique geography of the Island
In practice, the unique geography and demography of the Island most likely means that we do not need to reach the national level. As many of us do most of our driving within the confines of the Island, our annual mileages are relatively low – 5,000 to 7,000 miles per year.

The Island also has a lot of rural housing, where people have off-street parking and can rely on home chargers for almost all their charging needs, just topping up overnight and starting each day with a full battery.

New models can go further
While EVs of even just a few years ago had practical ranges of around 100 miles or less, the models now coming onto the market almost all have real world ranges in excess of 200 miles – which will take you around the Island four times!

What this means is that for most people driving EVs on the Island, they will only need to “fill up” once a week at most, though the habit of running the fuel tank down and then filling right up again will become a thing of the past.

Charging will become routine
As charge points start to pop up in supermarkets, pub carparks, cinemas and work places, refuelling with electricity will become as routine and opportunistic as charging your phone or paying to park.

You park, plug in and while you are shopping or enjoying a meal or film, your car is charging. You return to a car that is topped up, ready to go; cool in the summer, toasty warm and demisted in the winter. No queues to fill up, no worries about petrol station opening hours.

Charging infrastructure
Another aspect of charging infrastructure is the rate of charging. Common home chargers are rated at 7kW (about the same as an electric cooker with several rings on at once) and will take up to nine hours to fully charge a modern EV – so easily done overnight when the car is not needed.

This approach is good for the battery and has the additional advantage that electricity suppliers such as Octopus are offering special tariffs with lower prices at night – like Economy 7 but much smarter.

Making money from your EV
Soon chargers will become bi-directional, hooking up EVs to the grid so owners can receive income from allowing their cars to send out power at times when it is needed on the grid.

So called “destination chargers” – the sort being installed by supermarkets for example (The Co-op in Freshwater and Tesco Extra in Ryde being Island examples) are often rated at 22kW to 50kW (called fast and rapid chargers), so will do a full charge in one to three hours.

Charging will become part to the “furniture of life”
The lower rated chargers are often free, so while they will not do a full recharge while you do your shopping, you get a significant boost for nothing. (In half an hour a 22kW charger puts about 40 miles on the range).

Again, it is a matter of charging just becoming part to the “furniture of life” – a routine chore we do without much conscious thought, as part of other every-day activities.

Ultra-Rapid chargers
Ultra-Rapid chargers are only needed when you take your car off Island for long trips at motorway speeds. These chargers can take less than half an hour to fully recharge your car – time to stretch your legs and grab coffee before being on your way again.

This type of charging is expensive and can be hard on the battery, but it’s fine for the occasional long trip.

EVs will change many things in our lives
The rise of electric vehicles will change many things in our lives. Our “batteries on wheels” will be more closely integrated into our lives, making fuel station queues a thing of the past.

We will “fuel” our cars in all sorts of different places, a top-up here, a top-up there, just as we do with our phones.

Intellectual carriages
Like our phones, our EVs will be connected. They will know when power is cheap and so when is the best time to charge. They will be able to make us money by trading electricity in the market, and in extremis, they will be able to provide back-up power if our houses lose the mains.

This may all sound fanciful today, but in 1900 the owners of horse carriages thought the same about horseless carriages. Within twenty years their world was turned upside down, and technology moves at a much faster pace today.

Image: Ernest Ojeh under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
20 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Justin Case
10, January 2022 7:18 pm

EV charging is being held back by the failure to standardise the charger design and get them off the pavement. A new type of charge point designed to be flush into the road surface will be much cheaper to install and will stop the world being cluttered up with a new round of unsightly junk. It will also mean that cars will automatically engage with the charge… Read more »

Murun Buchstansangur
10, January 2022 9:39 pm

I nearly bought a fairly new plug-in EV. I am lucky enough to have a small driveway so would have only needed to charge it there, overnight. I can’t imagine anyone would buy an EV without the facility to charge it at home. So on the Island the public charging points would be virtually exclusively for holiday makers. Ok, as a tourist economy, I’m sure that’s still… Read more »

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  Murun Buchstansangur
11, January 2022 8:05 am

Because there are plenty of residents who want, or have EVs, that don’t have the luxury of off-street parking. Just imagine!

I know several personally, but also the IWC say they have received many complaints from residents asking for more on-street EV chargers.

Murun Buchstansangur
Reply to  Sally Perry
11, January 2022 8:15 am

You know people with a plug-in EV that don’t have their own off street charging facilities? Seems like a half-baked plan to me.

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  Murun Buchstansangur
11, January 2022 8:21 am

As I said before, yes I do. It’s not half-baked at all. One of them is someone who drives a great deal around the Island delivering classes. So long as the fast charger is working, they cope OK, but have been gagging for the ten on-street chargers that are installed and not yet operating, to be turned on. I guess doing their bit to help save the… Read more »

VentnorLad
Reply to  Sally Perry
11, January 2022 9:15 am

I don’t have off-street parking.
Living in Ventnor, it’s a rare day that I can even park a car outside my own home.
But as petrol/diesel motors are phased out over the next couple of decades, the infrastructure needs to start going in now.
In the imaginary world where I could buy a new car, it would be EV every single time.

davimel
Reply to  Sally Perry
11, January 2022 5:13 pm

The problem is that IF these charging points get turned on then more people will buy EVs’ and they will want more charging points, ad infinitum. I suspect that EV ownership is going to cause many problems here, especially during the Holiday season when perhaps hundreds more EV will appear, all expecting the charging facilities that Islanders will be fighting for. Let us not forget that there… Read more »

Dalek
10, January 2022 10:23 pm

Until they come up with one that will tow my caravan for a decent distance, I’ll stick to my trusty diesel.

elemental
11, January 2022 10:04 am

UK’s railways are still 62% diesel-run & there are few, if any electrified buses or replacement tram systems: We need a serious & determined shift to electrify basic essentials like Public Transport, too. Electric vehicles need to be Utilitarian & cheaper: Big enough to transport people but duplications of 4×4’s. For many people, vehicles aren’t just a solution for A to B; cars are personalised & for… Read more »

bobmills
Reply to  elemental
11, January 2022 12:39 pm

Over a 1000 electric/hybrid buses in London and rising all the time DLR fully electric Croydon tramway fully electric suggest you could perhaps do more research before stating the non obvious ☺️

vitabrevis
Reply to  bobmills
11, January 2022 3:35 pm

Just shows that it can be done, even in UK and with this feckless bunch in charge.

As for “I don’t believe this government is serious” – couldn’t agree more, unless we’re talking about lining the pockets of party donors and Ministers’ friends.

patricke
11, January 2022 10:32 am

I have had an EV since last March. I don’t have home charging, but it hasn’t been a problem. I would say though that the Island needs more reliable Rapid, 50 kwh + chargers. The supermarkets seem the best option for these, plug in, do your shopping, come back to a good top up. Very good article by the way.

vitabrevis
Reply to  patricke
11, January 2022 3:38 pm

It would be unfortunate if the success of electrification were to depend on the self-interest of Tesco and the like. Perhaps it could be made a Planning ondition that all new commercial builds/conversions provided publicly-acessible charging points?

patricke
Reply to  vitabrevis
12, January 2022 10:43 am

Indeed, but Supermarkets have the investment money and need to attract and hold customer loyalty. Appealing to and manipulating their prejudices ;-). Yes a planning requirement would be excellent.

Colin
12, January 2022 9:50 am

Those who read my comments on here will know that I have suggested many times before that the IWC utilise the land that they already own and provide designated parking with charging points. As an example, the Lugley Street car park in Newport could be developed into a multi storey car park each space being equipped with a charging point. This would solve the problem that many… Read more »

patricke
Reply to  Colin
12, January 2022 10:44 am

Big roof covered in solar panels would be great too.

Angela Hewitt
12, January 2022 3:02 pm

A really interesting article. Clearly open to criticism from those that have to consider their own personal position. Interestingly only yesterday I was discussing with one of my volunteers how we could offer a recharging service at Naturezones. This was subject was on my mind as I was driving home only to find myself in a 80 minute traffic jam while trying to get into Whippingham after… Read more »

patricke
Reply to  Angela Hewitt
12, January 2022 5:06 pm

When the EV is stationary it uses almost no electricity so you are unlikely to run out charge. My EV has a range of about 325 miles in mild weather. You don’t normally need to charge to 100%, most times 80% is fine and quickest to charge to.

colinpalmer
12, January 2022 7:58 pm

Thank you everyone for your comments. In may article I forgot to mention that Wight Community Energy have set up a Facebook group called IsleEV for discussing EVs on the Island. The link is https://www.facebook.com/groups/1211549025995422 I think many of the questions and concerns have been covered within the comments, but a couple of thoughts/comments from me. As patricke says, EVs use very little power when stopped in… Read more »

patricke
12, January 2022 8:06 pm

If you want to get a handle on where the electric vehicle industry has come from and where it is going, Sandy Munro is the go to guy. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=8fjeK2FKBjQ

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined