Does The Freedom Of The Press Matter?

We held the message below at the top of each of VentnorBlog’s pages from 4.Nov.08 until the 10th. We thought it was important that readers, who may have missed the detail that we had reported previously, had an idea of how things had been with the Communications department of the Isle of Wight Council.

Rather than just throw it away, we thought we’d post it.

Thanks to everyone who have added comments to this supportive thread on the forum, our June article and for the privately emailed messages of support sent to us so far, both from members of the public and some politicians. We really appreciate it.


Dear VB reader ….

“The proper functioning of a modern participatory democracy requires that the media be free, active, professional and inquiring.

For this reason the courts, here and elsewhere, have recognised the cardinal importance of press freedom and the need for any restriction on that freedom to be proportionate and no more than is necessary to promote the legitimate object of the restriction.”

Lord Bingham

House of Lords, 2000

VentnorBlog has for three years published news and events across the Isle of Wight – over 4,000 articles enjoying in excess of 25,000 page views every day – all at no cost to its readers.

Cut Off
At the end of April 2008, Claire Robertson, Head of Communications at the Isle of Wight Council, took the decision to cut off VentnorBlog (without telling us, as it happens), because she didn’t like the way we reported the facts.

The Communications department is hugely powerful. Since the introduction of a new communications policy at the council, any press contact must now go through that department.

The upshot? – all access to the council for VentnorBlog and you, its readers has been denied.

David Pugh
We have since the end of May been assured a number of times by David Pugh, Leader of the IW Council, that we should leave it to him to sort out.

Six months later and VentnorBlog remains cut off from every part of the council.

We fail to see how an organisation can call itself democratic and leave this position to remain.

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
9 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Mr T
10, November 2008 4:58 pm

Personally I hope you keep the message at the top of the page until the Communication department reverse such a perverse and childish decision or Claire Robertson (or whoever is ultimately responsible for this farcical and undemocratic death sentence for free speech) resigns.

adrian nicholas
10, November 2008 6:29 pm

to be effective the UK needs a constitution and amendment to existing human rights legislation. The IOW has only the IWC’s press and communications dept. and the IOW county press apart from yourselves which strangely enough is currently refused accreditation by an allegedly uncommunificative Claire Robertson. hmmmm- remember what happened to the wonderful ‘Island eye’. re-IOW radio- at a local tory party political level there was an… Read more »

musoactivator
11, November 2008 4:18 pm

I’m so glad I got out of these type of council shenanigans. It’s easier to force policies through when there is selective reporting on the matters that most don’t give many hoots about. Nothing changes and I found many who just shut up and took their salaries rather than question absurdities. Me? After transparant assistance for a few years I did not fancy turning into citizen Smith.… Read more »

roger regular
12, November 2008 3:05 pm

musoactivator, Hey not seen you for a while. Your last paragraph is getting close to my pet hate/love.
I wonder how much truth we will be given about Ryde theatre and why it is really “not cost effective”
A sample of bad planning. They have decided to put on an AC/DC tribute act (again), the same day as the Winter Gardens LOL

roger regular
12, November 2008 3:24 pm

Forgot, if they included the bar profit, then Ryde theatre is definitely cost effective, as R oops musoactivator is aware.
Muso, fancy a night at the Winter Gardens sometime?

kj
12, November 2008 3:40 pm

Pop into Hipshaker on Saturday and see if you think its viable, my bet is that it will be sold out again ( as it always is)

Bertie
12, November 2008 9:11 pm

Never mind about the freedom of the press, how about a little re-alignment of council policies. In every other sphere of interest, be it retail, technology, oil, banking etc. etc., people are losing their jobs due to the economic downturn. I, as you might expect, did a little research on my beloved friends in the planning department and found the following interesting stats., which are freely available… Read more »

musoactivator
13, November 2008 1:47 pm

Hey Rog. I’d be delighted for a trip to Ventnor Winter Gardens…I think they are doing a great job there.

Shame the busiest nights ryde theatre put on are from outside promoters so, apart from a good bar-take, they don’t receive the door.

Island Tories completely contradict Tory Party election promises – should they be trusted nationally? « All Wight
18, April 2010 2:08 pm

[…] Island Tories completely contradict Tory Party election promises – should they be trusted nationally? Despite David Cameron’s best assurances cutting funding for the police, schools, and the NHS will somehow result in better services for hand-shaking white people not fist-clenched fuzzie wuzzies, the Conservative administration responsible for running things on a local level doesn’t seem to be doing a very good job of eradicating waste and non-transparency.… Read more »