GCSE results: Mixed results across Island schools

Following individual GCSE results from Ryde Academy, Christ the King College and Ryde School, this in from the Isle of Wight council. In their own words. Ed

GCSE results for the Isle of Wight have been released today (23 August).

Cowes High School A-Level ResultsChrist the King College, the only school on the Island which has so far had pupils for the full secondary range (11 to 16 year olds), has seen 77.1 percent of students achieve five or more A* – C grades including English and Maths, which is a record for the Isle of Wight and also places the college well above last year’s national average.

Ryde Academy also produced impressive results, rising almost nine percentage points compared to last year with 50.6 percent of students achieving five or more A* – C grades inc English and Maths. Cowes Enterprise College saw a slight rise, improving from 48 percent last year to 49.2 per cent in 2012.

Drop for three high schools
However, Carisbrooke College, Medina College and Sandown Bay Academy all returned lower results compared to 2011 which has impacted on the Isle of Wight’s overall percentage.

Sandown dropped ten percentage points, slipping from 50 percent in 2011 to 40 percent this year for students achieving five or more A* – C grades including English and Maths.

Carisbrooke dropped almost sixteen percentage points, from 51 percent last year to 35.1 percent this year in the five or more A* – C grades including English and Maths indicator.

Medina dropped the most, from 52 percent to 32.5 percent this year. Overall, the Isle of Wight has seen a drop, from 49.5 percent in 2011 to 44.2 percent in 2012.

Christ the King College sets the bar
Janet Newton, Isle of Wight Council deputy director for schools and education said: “Firstly we should say how pleased we are for the staff and students at Christ the King College who have achieved the highest ever GCSE results on the Island and they deserve our praise and congratulations.

“This sets a high bar for all the other secondary providers for when they too have had the students for the full five years of secondary education. They have set the example for other providers to follow.

“Following on from a ‘good’ judgement in terms of Ofsted inspection, with the potential to be outstanding, we are working with the College and the two dioceses to ensure that all planning requirements for their sixth form are met. This will mean that, subject to planning approval, work on the additional building space for the sixth form can be undertaken as soon as practicable.

“We are delighted with the significant rise at Ryde Academy, bringing its results closer to the national average. Cowes Enterprise College also improved upon last year’s results, giving it a good platform for its forthcoming move into the new building.”

Simply not good enough
She went on to say, “However, the results at Carisbrooke, Medina and Sandown are simply not good enough and are the sole reason why the Isle of Wight has seen a reduction in the numbers of students achieving five or more A* to C grades. There will be some very tough questions for these schools and we will want answers as to why their performances have been so bad.”

Dawn Cousins, Isle of Wight Council cabinet member responsible for education and children’s services said: “It is a very nervous time opening your exam results and I hope individual students got the grades they wanted.

“Unfortunately, the good work of Cowes and Ryde, and in particular Christ the King, has been affected by the results provided by Sandown, Medina and Carisbrooke.

“For Carisbrooke to drop almost 16 percentage points, Medina nearly 20 percentage points and Sandown ten percentage points in a year is wholly unacceptable and we will be seeking urgent meetings with the providers as a matter of priority.

“There is no good reason why what the three successful schools have achieved should not be emulated by the others. Cowes, Ryde and Christ the King have risen to the challenge offered by the new two-tier system and the others now need to do the same.

“On a positive note we should mention Christ the King’s results in particular. The students sitting the exams have had five years of education without interruption, i.e. they stayed in the same school continuously from the age of 11.

“This is the model which the Isle of Wight has now adopted and in a few years all students at every secondary provider will have not had any interruption across this key age range. Christ the King has led the way, and now it’s up to the other secondary providers to follow and produce impressive GCSE results.”

Support for young people
If you received your GCSE exam results today and want some advice, the Isle of Wight Council’s participation team offers independent and impartial support to all young people during the exam results period.

The team can be found at 29 High Street, Newport, P030 1SS and can be contacted on (01983) 525927.

The team operate a ‘drop-in’ service where no appointment is necessary. The opening times are Monday to Thursday 9.30am to 12.30pm then 1pm to 4pm and Friday 9.30am to 12.30pm then 1pm to 4pm.

A qualified participation adviser will meet with you in a safe and confidential environment and help you to explore the full range of options that are open to you including further and higher education, as well as training and employment opportunities.

If you are not returning to full-time education or training, a dedicated adviser can work with you and can then be contacted directly either by phone, email or by visiting the centre. The service can also make referrals to a wide range of training providers, employers and other agencies.


Image: dcjohn under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
47 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Concernedparent
23, August 2012 3:45 pm

As a concerned parent of a pupil at carisbrooke i am now very concerned about my childs future edication? The results from carisbrooke and medina (who are federated) are shocking and they have failed a whole group of young children! Some swift action is required i feel? Why has it taken so long to find a replacement head at carisbrooke? What exactly does this chief executive do… Read more »

Cynic
23, August 2012 4:12 pm

Other than Ryde Academy is the new Academy system failing its pupils on the Island? ISLAND INNOVATION TRUST Carisbrooke College dropped 15% 5+ A*-C inc EM, dropped 8% 5+ A*-C and dropped 2% 1 A*-G. Medina dropped 20% 5+ A*-C inc EM, dropped 8% 5+ A*-C and while increasing by 1% 1 A*-G. ACADEMIES ENTERPRISE TRUST Sandown Bay dropped 10%in 5+ A*-C inc EM, dropped 5% 5+… Read more »

tracey
23, August 2012 4:59 pm

is anyone really suprised, the way the schools have been up in the air this year its a wonder any of the pupils got A & A* ,congratulation to those that did! If I could I would now pay for private schools, loved the schools before the big change over

jennycannell
Reply to  tracey
24, August 2012 12:03 am

I agree with Tracey, the council have ruined our education system, all in the name of saving money…. and it is our children’s education and future that will suffer. Sandown Bay is the second largest school in the country, far too big for teachers to know pupils and their needs…. I don’t blame the teachers, they have no say in the school size…come on IOWCC, get your… Read more »

Alex
23, August 2012 5:53 pm

As a parent of two pupils at Ryde, I am stunned that the results have gone up. All I hear is how awful everything is and how uninspiring their lessons are. I suspect I will get shot down for this comment but I think the teachers are having a rubbish time too……

inside eyes
23, August 2012 6:45 pm

Not surprised at Medinas results at all, its like a war zone there! Police there every day. How do the ones who want to learn get on with all that going on. Maybe they should spend less on ipads and concentrate on proper teaching

DP
23, August 2012 6:57 pm

Maybe Janet and Dawn should look a bit closer to home for the reasons for this spectacular failure. The morale of teachers and teaching assistants is very low due to concern about the reorganisation and job cuts. Many teachers were forced to accept jobs they are not equipped to deal with purely because there was no alternative. There is only one reason for this decline and thats… Read more »

James P
23, August 2012 6:58 pm

“will be some very tough questions for these schools”

But not for the council that b***ered up the system in the first place?

Cynic
Reply to  James P
23, August 2012 7:00 pm

…. that will come in May 2013 at the next election!

Don Smith
Reply to  Cynic
23, August 2012 8:17 pm

Rubbish Mr Cynic – This is Tory island.

Children are not doing well, because of the lack of discipline in the schools, and this stems from lack of discipline in many of the children’s homes –
PARENTS GET A GRIP –

Far too many holidays; I’d scrap the six week break, Children forget what they have been taught.
It also allows some teachers time to moonlight.

Cynic
Reply to  Don Smith
23, August 2012 8:43 pm

@ Don Smith “This is Tory Island…lack of discipline in the schools…. lack of discipline in many of the children’s homes…PARENTS GET A GRIP..Far too many holidays.. scrap the six week break.. It allows some teachers time to moonlight. …………………………………….. You forgot…. Harrumph restore Victorian values, doncher know! Bring back workhouses! Breed more child chimney-sweeps! Bring back hanging the lash and transportation! Send a gunboat! Where the… Read more »

jennycannell
Reply to  Don Smith
24, August 2012 12:05 am

Don Smith, do you have children in school…the councils reorganisation was a shambles and our children are suffering from the fall out, that’s the be all and end all of it.

Gallybagger
Reply to  jennycannell
24, August 2012 12:42 am

The council may have to take some of the blame for the amalgamation of schools but try to think why austerity measures are in place and the money had to be saved. Wasn’t it Labour who put us in this financial mess so are therefore indirectly responsible for such dire results. A lot of kids have no discipline in their lives, they all know their ‘yuman rights’… Read more »

No.5
Reply to  jennycannell
24, August 2012 2:28 am

Ah the nievity of those who believe Tory Spin and blame culture….we have had a deficit for over a hundred years and our current deficit is not even the worst it has beem…Heaths was worse. When Labour lost power, we were climbing out of recession ( a world wide recession caused by banks across the world – not Labour)that climb has now been lost and we are… Read more »

Cynic
Reply to  jennycannell
24, August 2012 9:25 am

@galleybagger “Wasn’t it Labour who put us in this financial mess so are therefore indirectly responsible for such dire results.” Here comes the hoary old myth again used as an excuse whenever the Coalition gets into trouble. Look at the facts. For eleven years until 2008 the public debt as a percentage of Gross National Product remained below that inherited from the previous Tory government. Additional to… Read more »

Gallybagger
Reply to  jennycannell
24, August 2012 11:11 am

Wow, don’t you know politics. Personally i support neither side. I’m not defending ‘Tories’ (you sound like Rick from the young ones). My opinion is that the party in charge failed to deal with the deficit, got rich on it and got democratically voted out. Going back to the core reason for posting, too many people feel they have a god given right to income without working… Read more »

Cynic
Reply to  jennycannell
24, August 2012 3:29 pm

@galleybagger “My opinion is that the party in charge failed to deal with the deficit, got rich on it and got democratically voted out.”

Are you making a prediction for 2015? :-))

Kate
Reply to  James P
24, August 2012 5:34 pm

Do you think the tough question might be have your results been affected by the changes in the grade boundaries for English that has been all over the national news and has been acknowledged by the exam boards?! This may havehad an enormous impact upon results nationally and on the Isle of Wight. Have our esteemed coucillors and LEA commentators bothered to check if the better results… Read more »

Addmanniw
23, August 2012 7:20 pm

Sorry am I correct that this is the first year Christ the King has offered GCSE’s? And it is also correct the school is based in Newport alongside Medina & Carisbrooke? Now I guess having a much smaller year 11, many of whom would otherwise be attending Newport’s other 2 schools and bringing up their averages would have nothing to do with these results? Of course Sandown… Read more »

parent
Reply to  Addmanniw
23, August 2012 7:34 pm

Christ the King College pulls pupils from the whole Island so would not necessarily affect the results of Medina or Carisbrooke. Maybe its time to give credit where credit is due?

jennycannell
Reply to  parent
24, August 2012 12:07 am

Christ the King should be congratulated, but it should also be noted that they are a much smaller school, allowing them to know their pupils and offer extra support where needed!!

tracey
Reply to  jennycannell
24, August 2012 7:44 am

My 3 at Sandown Bay and far too big, the children walk from Sandown to Sandham for lesson what every the weather, no where for them to leave wet coats sit in wet clothes for rest of day and some kids even go walk about!!!! There hasnt been a week go by when one of mine havent come home and said the teacher has walked out of… Read more »

Wendy V
23, August 2012 7:52 pm

I remember Steve Beynon saying at meetings during the consultation about reorganisation that statistically the island didn’t have “a spread” of GCSE results across its schools, like other local authorities; ours were all lumped in the middle. Well, we’ve got a spread now, alright. Are we supposed to celebrate?

Chris
23, August 2012 10:19 pm

So, who *didnt* see this coming? The council should hang their heads in shame. #pughmustgo

Matt
23, August 2012 10:30 pm

Very simple, too many middle school teachers being thrown into a bigger pond with no experience or training of the exam system. Many of these teachers are primary school trained and fun themselves in the secondary system either through choice or the council taking the view that once qualified a teacher may teach any subject, and not necessarily their specialism (a big cause of the rot nationally).… Read more »

Aliow
24, August 2012 6:33 am

Well done to all the pupils that sat exams at Christ the King Collage this year.
Keep up the good. So glad we sent our daughter to this Collage

Cath
24, August 2012 8:27 am

Good Lord…..assuming some of the comments above are from parents, it’s hardly surprising that the kids are struggling!

Doesn’t education start at home? If the parents struggle with spelling and grammar then there’s not much hope for the children.

Rant over!

J
Reply to  Cath
24, August 2012 11:13 pm

Thanks Roger. A valid observation… for home tuition.

W.H Inger
Reply to  Cath
24, August 2012 11:52 pm

An ellipsis is three dots…just sayin’!

Don Smith
Reply to  W.H Inger
27, August 2012 2:03 am

Cath, please take note: An ellipsis is three dots…just sayin’!

But what the (‘) and the space between the (‘) and the (!) is for I can’t understand. And for (is) read (has) Just writing! Not saying.

And five (…..) Come on Cath, your kids just may read your post:-)

Caitlin
24, August 2012 11:12 am

As a pupil of Christ the King, I’m so proud to go to my school and that we got such a good first set of results. The school currently has around a thousand pupils (about to expand) which is I’m guessing less than the others. I’m not sure if that actually contributes to the grades, but I do know that the teaching here is excellent, which does… Read more »

jennycannell
Reply to  Caitlin
24, August 2012 7:44 pm

Caitlin, It is nice to hear that you are proud of your school. You commented on the fact that your teachers know you and give support and as you say ‘Genuinely care about us personally’ unfortunately, with Sandown being the second largest school in the country, the teachers barely get time to know each pupil…and yes the fact that it is such a large school would have… Read more »

Jenny
26, August 2012 4:41 pm

My son attends Medina and quite frankly I am sick of the schools all being compared to one another. This is not about who’s got the best school, this about every child reaching their potential. I do not agree with the reorganisation, and I blame the IW Council solely for this mess. Please remember that Christ the King have done very well, but they are two years… Read more »

Wendy V
Reply to  Jenny
26, August 2012 5:29 pm

I sympathise with you, Jenny. It’s going to take a while for the dust to settle, and I can think of good reasons the high schools have had a hard transition to full secondaries. They had to incorporate three new years groups and new staff when the middle schools closed. The new buildings dangled as carrots during the consultation didn’t materialise (except for Cowes, which already had… Read more »

Wendy V
Reply to  Wendy V
26, August 2012 5:33 pm

Rushed that reply, sorry! Should be “year groups” not “years groups”! And to clarify: I mean my daughters did extremely well; their school was at or just below the national average in terms of results.

jennycannell
Reply to  Wendy V
26, August 2012 6:05 pm

The problem is in the time it takes for ‘the dust to settle’ our children’s education is suffering. My two eldest went to Sandown High School and it was a really good school where the teachers knew the children (obviously a smaller school then) My youngest has just finished her GCSE’s but has chosen to go to Havant 6th Form College as it is a lot smaller… Read more »

Kate
Reply to  jennycannell
26, August 2012 10:50 pm

I am confident that no secondary school on the Island, are teachers taken off 6 th Form teaching to cover lower school lessons. This is the sort of ridiculous rumour that undermines te efforts of schools to do their very best for theirstudents, under sometimes intolerable circumstances.t

Kate
26, August 2012 10:45 pm

I’m sorry, this comment makes no sense. Even in a big school, teachers don’t teach more students, so individual teachers do get to know their students well. The issue is a different one; in a larger school, everyone doesn’t know everyone else, which may not suit some students.

jennycannell
Reply to  Kate
27, August 2012 12:31 am

I have to disagree with you Kate, this definitely happens, I have had friends children whom have experienced this over the last 2years.I for one am not prepared to risk my daughters future by restricting her education to the Island where the education system is a mess, unhappy pupils and staff do not make for a good learning environment.The teachers do not have the time to get… Read more »

sandownian
Reply to  Kate
27, August 2012 8:54 am

Sorry Kate,

Although the classes may be of a similar size, this past year at Sandown (can’t speak for other schools) we seldom had the same teacher each time. Different supply teachers came and went. And to answer your previous post, many times in the 6th Form we had to study without a teacher due to staff shortages

BRIAN
27, August 2012 7:52 am

Having worked for 32 years in education, my observations on the situation are as follows: The teaching staff. Parents often send children to a specific school because the staff is perceived to be better or superior to staff in other schools. As far as I am aware, when a person is interviewed for a position, no question is asked concerning the college where qualified and no training… Read more »

ACW
Reply to  BRIAN
27, August 2012 7:59 am

So, how do you explain Ryde Academy’s excellent results?

standards
Reply to  ACW
27, August 2012 8:59 am

Are you defining “Excellent” as well below national average?

BRIAN
Reply to  BRIAN
27, August 2012 11:43 am

One thing I forgot to add concerns the teachers. All teachers want to do the best for their pupils and will work hard when they see pupils willing to work themselves. Teachers don’t wish to spend their working week constantly quelling noise and dealing with discipline issues. Thus, if a vacancy arises in a middle class catchment area they will apply because having attentive, hard-working pupils, makes… Read more »

jennycannell
Reply to  BRIAN
27, August 2012 12:01 pm

Brian, you do have some valid points, but children with special needs and a statement can not be refused entry to the school of their choice, this by its nature sometimes leads to disruption within the class, even in a ‘middle class’ area as you put it. According to the ‘Children’s Act’ 1989, all children have a right to an education not disrupted by others, until the… Read more »

brian
Reply to  jennycannell
31, August 2012 5:23 pm

With respect to special needs I have some experience of this. Up until the 1960’s there were special schools for children who were disgracefully referred to as E.S.N. (Educationally Sub-normal). Thank goodness we now live in more enlightened times. An educationalist – a lady whose name escapes me – had the idea that, where appropriate, special needs children should be educated in main stream schools. Government and… Read more »

Alex
14, November 2012 1:26 am

As someone who left the Island, UK too, some 46 years ago, I read these articles about educational achievement in the UK with disappointment. The over-reaching demand for academia in my mind is wrong. The emphasis on as many subjects as possible, the tougher the better, similarly all with the highest grade is misguided. The prominence should be about choice of school and their outcomes; by that… Read more »

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined