Blueprints

Housing plans to replace former nursing home set for approval

Plans to build ten houses on an Isle of Wight Council-owned property in Shanklin look set to be approved tonight (Tuesday).

A new application, recommended for approval at tonight’s planning committee, has been submitted after a previous scheme was turned down due to a lack of parking.

The application has been submitted by PSP Isle of Wight LLP, on behalf of the council.

Replacing nursing home
Ten houses, with two or three bedrooms, would replace Elmdon House — a four-storey domestic Victorian villa formerly used as a nursing home.

The application says:

“Elmdon House is neither special in form nor detail. It is a fairly ordinary example of a Victorian villa, which is now in very poor condition.”

Residents have expressed concern over the plans.

Neighbour: Density too high
Brian Cullum, who lives near the site, said the high density of houses would make the space crowded.

He said:

“They are only building 16 parking spaces however, most people have their own car so that will mean 20 cars needing parking.”

Gardens removed for parking
A previous application, submitted in September 2017, only planned for 13 parking spaces. To accommodate the additional three spaces, two front gardens have been removed.

Objections were also raised by the tree officer who said the proximity of parking to important trees would lead to the loss of those trees — they reccomended the loss of two housing units to mitigate this.

Under the new application, the site layout has been amended, keeping all ten units.

Image: Keoni under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
0 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Simon Haytack
22, March 2013 11:07 am

Interesting the choice for Newport East is the old Councillor for Chale, Niton & Whitwell, who resigned in 2010 due to work commitments.

Also, why is Roger Dixcey standing for Newport South AND Parkhurst?!

danielclarke
Reply to  Simon Haytack
22, March 2013 11:58 am

Very unlikely that he will win anyway as Newport East is about the only place on the island which is a traditional labour ward.

Simon Haytack
Reply to  Sally Perry
22, March 2013 12:21 pm

I thought that would probably have been the case. Thanks for the confirmation.

Robbo
Reply to  Simon Haytack
23, March 2013 1:02 pm

And the consequent by-election when he stood down there after just 15 months would have cost the Council taxpayer a few bob.

steve s
22, March 2013 11:26 am

“Conservative councillors have a strong track record of listening to the concerns of local residents, rolling their sleeves up and getting things done. Many are involved in local initiatives and parish council activity, as well as serving on school governing bodies and other local organisations. The group of Conservative councillors work together as a team to make the right decisions for the Island’s future, and give the… Read more »

Rupert Besley
Reply to  steve s
22, March 2013 12:28 pm

Well, my councillor (Conservative) did not reply on either occasion that I wrote to him.

tiki
22, March 2013 11:58 am

Pardon? ‘Listening to the concerns of local residents’. Someone is having a laugh.Typical Pugh arrogance. This will be the first year I will NOT be voting Conservative. Once again the out of touch Tories in Cowes select candidates with yachtie connections. What happened to grass roots candidates like Cllr Peacey-Wilcox? Perhaps she saw the light. Shame really because she was one of the hardest working Cllrs. I’m… Read more »

danielclarke
22, March 2013 12:01 pm

In the county press today, geoff lumley said there were over 20 candidates confirmed. Does anyone know about these, all i know is kevin barclay jay in sandown north.

DH
22, March 2013 12:10 pm

I had my local conservative councillor turn up on my door step a couple of days ago. I asked him about the PFI. He said to me the council failed to communicate exactly what it’s about. He said the PFI is not a loan but a gift from Westminster because they’ve seen the state of the roads over here on the Island. He also mentioned that we… Read more »

PW
Reply to  DH
22, March 2013 1:22 pm

‘PFI is a Gift from Westminster’
You could not make this up, could you? Its more like a script from Dibley!!
And Tidal Power comments from a standing a councillor makes you wonder if they have been asleep for 8 years or just drifting??

tiki
22, March 2013 12:16 pm

Labour haven’t done themselves any favours, where have they been the last few years? They should have been out there raising their profile and cashing in on the discontent! I’m afraid they will spend a few more years in the wilderness yet. At least we have a few very good Independent candidates. Paul Fuller springs to mind. If people want change they have to vote for it,… Read more »

danielclarke
Reply to  tiki
22, March 2013 12:31 pm

I’m not a labour supporter but I expect they may pick up a couple of wards like Lake North and Ryde South where they have done quite well in past elections and by elections as well as holding Newport East.

Cynic
22, March 2013 12:25 pm

Why did it take so long for David Pugh to show his hand in the 2013 3l3ction?

Note: 50% of the current Cabinet (i.e.)Delegated Decision makers are not standing.

Mason Watch
22, March 2013 12:25 pm

Arthur “trouser leg at half mast” Taylor? Ooooooo!
Also Susan “that’s quite enough of that peasants” Scoccia…… Should be interesting. Next time a Tory appears on your doorstep say you’ll vote for them if they get rid of the boy Pugh

Meursault
22, March 2013 2:05 pm

A copy of my local Conservative candidate’s manifesto was popped through my door this week. On the generic side they list the following eight points they are planning to address: – Council Tax Frozen – Reducing Fuel Costs – Housing Priority for those seeking work – Getting Around the Island – Apprenticeships – Attracting Investment & Jobs – Solent Energy Centre – Promoting Tourism Which all sounds… Read more »

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined