‘It’ll be like Handforth’ was the pitch to us re Lake Parish Council’s Zoom call. How could we resist?

It had been pitched to News OnTheWight that Lake Parish Council’s debate on controlling public questions could reach the dizzying heights of the much-adored Handforth Parish Council last night, so how could we resist? Here’s what happened

Lake parish council zoom meeting blurred

News OnTheWight were told that last night’s Lake Parish Council meeting, a debate about changes to the Standing Orders, had the potential to almost become viral.

Cllr Bob Blezzard had put forward a motion proposing restrictions to the number of questions members of the public can ask, and how.

He proposed that online meetings should be restricted to written questions only, and they should be submitted to the Clerk at least 24 hours in advance. Not only that, but only one question, not exceeding 150 words, could be asked.

Read the Standing Orders
During the public question time it was claimed the process had breached the Parish Council’s very own Standing Orders, as it had only been proposed in writing by one councillor, not two.

The Chairperson, Sue Horton, tried to attach herself to the motion saying she agreed with it and would be the second councillor, but it was pointed out repeatedly by Cllr Adrian Whitaker that this still breached the Standing Orders, as it hadn’t been done in advance of the meeting.

Further objections
Former parish councillor, John Marshall, who resigned over the public toilet mix-up last year, said the motion had not been submitted “two days beforehand in writing by two council members” and asked for the Proper Officer’s comments. The Clerk, Mike Taplin, said he thought believed the motion was in order.

A proposal to defer the debate until the next meeting was seconded by Cllr Tig Outlaw.

Brading: “Personally motivated”
Cllr Paul Brading said he felt the motion seemed “personally motivated rather than business motivated”. He asked why it was coming forward now, after months of remote meetings, adding,

“I do feel it’s a reaction to recent meetings where Cllr Blezzard became agitated with certain members of the public.”

He asked all councillors to,

“Consider your position very carefully about the decision to try and silence the public, ruining the good relationship Lake PC has with its residents.”

Horton: “Using up broadband”
The Chairperson (Cllr Horton) argued that it was difficult to see and hear people on the Zoom calls and having written questions would be more favourable until they returned to face-to-face meetings.

She said questions being asked about subjects that “aren’t necessarily relevant” would be using up people’s broadband allocations.

Member of the public, Steve Parkes – who said he would be standing for the council in the May elections – said he felt the motion was “pretty much aimed at me”, which Cllr Horton denied, arguing that it was about asking questions that were not relevant to Lake.

Vote to carry on with debate
Cllr Horton called a vote as to whether to go ahead with the debate and it was voted five in favour, with three against.

Cllr Whitaker enthusiastically announced that any councillors who voted on the motion would be reported to the Monitoring Officer the next morning.

Blezzard: “I don’t react to threats”
Cllr Blezzard went ahead to propose his motion, adding that he noted Cllr Whittaker’s comments, adding “I don’t react to threats”.

He said his motion was “based on changes made to Isle of Wight council constitution and if it is good enough for IWC it should be good enough for Lake PC”.

He added that they had already seen “one would-be councillor abusing question time”.

Deferred until next meeting
The Chair agreed to leave the vote until next month when they would have a new proposal with two signatures.

Lake Parish Council meetings are held on the second Wednesday of the month. See their Website for more details.

Thursday, 11th February, 2021 10:46am


ShortURL: http://wig.ht/2ofx

Filed under: Island-wide, Isle of Wight News, Lake, Top story

Any views or opinions presented in the comments below must comply with the Commenting 'House Rules' and are solely those of the author and do not represent those of OnTheWight.

Leave your Reply

3 Comments on "‘It’ll be like Handforth’ was the pitch to us re Lake Parish Council’s Zoom call. How could we resist?"

newest oldest most voted

Whilst having some amusement value, it is a shame that the antics of a few tarnish the often unappreciated good voluntary job many Town and Parish councils do. I do attend my local PC meetings occasionally as a member of the public and am grateful to those who willingly give their time to sort through the often tedium of local matters.

Although I am not aware of the goings on at the meeting I do get the feeling that there is little very team work in this council and that there appears to be a lot of personal animosity between council members and council members and members of the public. Surely as a members they should work together for the good of the community not griping at each… Read more »
Mark L Francis

Wasn’t it Sandown Council that called in the police to stop people asking questions?
Don’t suppose there is a Zoom Police? (yet)