Letter To The Editor: Formal Complaint to the Secretary of State

One reader shares his views on the changes to the library service on the Isle of Wight and asks for your help. Ed

Dear Editor,

Following the Councils decision to still cut five libraries despite it only saving £236,000, I decided to take a look at the Public Libraries & Museums Act 1964.

It appears that our delightful leaders have actually broken the terms of the Act. In Section 7 of the Act it states that the Statutory Authority (in our case the IWC) has a duty to provide a comprehensive and efficient Library Service at NO COST TO THE USER.

Users will be paying through precept increases
In view of the IWC trying to get Parish Councils to “volunteer” to run libraries for the council, parish precepts will rise to cover the costs.

Therefore, as the books, computer and premises will still be owned by the IWC, we, the tax payers will pick up an extra bill for a service that the council has a duty to provide free of charge.

Complaint to Secretary of State
I have put together a formal complaint to the Secretary of State, much of it based on a similar complaint launched in one of the London Boroughs a few days ago, that was put together, as I understand, by legal minds.

I have addressed my complaint as being from Friends of The IW Library Service and as such I would like at least one voter from each of the five areas due to lose their IWC funded library to sign the document so that it represents the whole Island.

Of course, if anyone can suggest ways of improving the complaint, I will be happy to modify the document.

If you would like to see the document or would like to sign the final version, please contact me at djqhda@yahoo.co.uk

Thanks DaveQ

Image: Bensonkua under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
22 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
ABC
10, March 2011 9:23 am

Best of luck with your letter. I cannot sign as I do not live in an area which will lose a IW Council-funded library but I am with you in spirit.

keithybaby
10, March 2011 9:32 am

I’d be willing to sign, although may be from the same area as yourself? East Cowes

Martin William Wareham
10, March 2011 9:35 am

Dave can help willing to sign if o.k.I live in Brighstone. nobbyw@hotmail.com

Sandra O'Toole
10, March 2011 9:46 am

Well done Dave but it seems like theyve already decided? Was the protesting a waste of time??

rosie
Reply to  Sandra O'Toole
11, March 2011 9:58 am

this is not a waste of time, it is a very serious situation, legal solicitors are now putting a file against the iwcc, no one should give up, if your interested in saving the libraries you can join in to help….

Asite2c
10, March 2011 9:52 am

Well done Dave. This is proof that these leaders in Government are prepared to break the laws and acts they create. I wonder how many other acts similar to this are just ignored and broken by Government and Council departments. I doubt whether they’ll take any notice and probably reply with a load of spin and lies as they wear blinkers and don’t don’t live in the… Read more »

LooLoo
10, March 2011 10:00 am

Are Pugh and the village idiots at County Hall aware of this act or is it too complicated for them to understand?

Best of luck with the letter.

Julia Hill
10, March 2011 10:04 am

I’ll sign, although I am from East Cowes too…I would be happy for the Ed to pass on my email to you.

James Arrow
Reply to  Julia Hill
10, March 2011 10:33 am

Now we need an injunction against the council to stop them from closing any libraries and halt them in their tracks.

John R
10, March 2011 10:41 am

Dave, you may also be able to ‘gleen’ some more information from the issues raised when this was attempted in Liverpool. This led to the Goverment holding a Public enquiry.

DaveQ
Reply to  John R
10, March 2011 11:24 am

Many thanks for the replies, I have parts of the report on the Wirral case a couple of years ago, and Hillingdon are following the same route this time. As I understand it there is also a legal challenge going in nationally accusing the Secretary of State of failing in his duty to uphold the 1964 Act. Over the next hour I will contact those who have… Read more »

James Arrow
Reply to  DaveQ
11, March 2011 12:53 am

Start with a solicitor’s letter and then begin fundraising to pay for the initial court appearance.

Asite2c
10, March 2011 11:30 am

In Section 7 of the Act it states that the Statutory Authority (in our case the IWC) has a duty to provide a comprehensive and efficient Library Service at NO COST TO THE USER. Don’t be surprised if they spin this part of the act to justify library closures and say “The IOW Council have broken no act as they are still providing a comprehensive service”. Even… Read more »

Janet
10, March 2011 11:45 am

Dave We think the SoS has received many letters about this, the problem is the decision has been made by IOW Council.It is therefore important to keep the libraries operating in some way in the existing buildings in case we can get the decision reversed Public Interest Lawyers who are representing Gloucestershire and Somerset residents, taking the cases to the High Court have said that the Island… Read more »

DaveQ
Reply to  Janet
10, March 2011 11:56 am

Janet, I think I might qualify for legal aid, plrasse email me and I’ll get back to you
Dave

rosie
Reply to  DaveQ
10, March 2011 12:13 pm

to all those interested, who can qualify for legal aid there is already solicitors who are dealing with the isle of wight , but they need as many people as possible to sign for legal aid, who can represent all sides of the island , they have been collecting evidence for some time and now feel they have enough to go forward, please if anyone can help… Read more »

rosie
Reply to  Janet
10, March 2011 1:34 pm

if you have any info on your library such as the precept please forward to leigh day solicitors , they are collecting everything so as they can proceed, hopefully now you have put this on ventnorblog there will be many who can come forward to help.

Z. Morgan
10, March 2011 2:57 pm

I live in Cowes and the Town Council have not raised the precept. 4 town Councillors and 3 library supporters (of which I am one!) are in the process of organising a ‘Forum’ that is going to try and ‘manage’ the Library here in Cowes alongside the IOW Council.We will be posting adverts on the Town Council noticeboard, Library and in Cowes Primary School Newsletter asking for… Read more »

rosie
Reply to  Z. Morgan
10, March 2011 4:30 pm

cowes is one of the libraries to be saved, are you implying that you dont trust the iwcc to keep their promise ,why do have these fears you need to pass them onto the solicitors that are dealing with this, what are your reasons ect, we need to gather all the info possible .

DaveQ
Reply to  rosie
10, March 2011 7:32 pm

Hi Rosie, would you trust the IWC? I certainly wouldn’t, they’ve still got a further 3 years when the budget has to be reduced by another £8million a year!! What’s for the chop next year?
I’d rather trust a rattlesnake that I’d trod on than David Pugh and his axemen.

No future
Reply to  Z. Morgan
10, March 2011 8:28 pm

Do you not realise that by volunteering, you are playing into their hands. Staff numbers are being reduced drastically and the quality of service will drop accordingly. Well done!!

rosie
Reply to  No future
10, March 2011 9:31 pm

this is exactly why many of us are trying to still fight against this decision. if there are fears in cowes that their library will still be under threat of closure then they need to join us , give all their reasons to the solicitors , volunteers need to know that they will be expected to run a library the same as a profesional librarian does now,… Read more »