waiting room

Some Isle of Wight GP surgeries ‘one incident away from collapse’

More GP surgeries could face the same fate as Sandown Medical Centre, a senior health boss has warned.

Dr Timothy Whelan, the deputy clinical chair of the Isle of Wight Clinical Commissioning Group, said some surgeries were just ‘one incident away from collapse’.

Speaking at the Isle of Wight Health and Wellbeing board meeting today (Thursday), he said the Isle of Wight had a real problem with recruitment and retention of GPs and nurses.

He said:

“We have heard about Sandown having to close their lists, and I would say that around the country too — it’s not just an Isle of Wight problem — there remain practices which feel they are just one incident away from collapse, and that is certainly the case on the Island.

“I have been speaking to quite a few practices on this Island which are really struggling, every bit as much as Sandown and we can only hope Sandown is now given the breathing space to reorganise itself and to reopen and provide the full service that it used to.

“We need to be aware that the same fate could quite quickly befall other practices on the Island.”

Fears have been raised the Island’s GP recruitment crisis is spiralling out of control, and last week Sandown Medical Centre closed its lists to new patients, except where they are immediate family members of existing patients, due to a shortage of doctors.

The clinic hopes to reopen the list this autumn after taking on a newly qualified GP. The centre applied to close its list for 12 months, but only a six-month closure was approved.

Dr Whelan said the crisis was a reflection of a wider national problem.

“With the council, we share all these woes,” he said.

“There has been quite a lot to say about housing — the health and wellbeing of every population has remarkably little to do with doctors and nurses, but housing, education, employment and transport and of course the council has major influence over those factors.”

He said these factors were also preventing the recruitment of good doctors and nurses.

“Why would good doctors or nurses, looking for a job, come to the Island when they discover the schools are sub-optimal, there are limited employment opportunities for partners and the housing stock is rather limited?”

He said the council, trust and CCG should work together to fix these issues.


This article is from the BBC’s LDRS (Local Democracy Reporter Service) scheme, which OnTheWight is taking part in. Some additions by OnTheWight. Ed

Image: christinawelsh under CC BY 2.0

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
9 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Alternative Perspective
26, July 2018 5:22 pm

In addition to Dr Timothy Whelan’s astute observations, many GP practices have tried to plug the gap with locums, often retired GP’s wanting to earn a little extra beer money, but this is not a long term solution, and often does not significantly lift the administrative burden on full time staff. Our Hospital has historically paid many staff a band lower than colleagues doing comparable work on… Read more »

njb249
26, July 2018 8:32 pm

The only way to attract the young professionals to the island is to provide 24/7 all weather access to and from the mainland. That includes doctors, nurses, school teachers and high tech business people. If we don’t then the island will continue to die.

iowdave
Reply to  njb249
27, July 2018 2:22 pm

Sorry, but the only way to provide 24/7 all-weather access to and from the mainland is via a tunnel and that will take a long time to be built. I know that this comment will attract many down votes but it’s time we stopped burying our heads in the sand.

Alternative Perspective
Reply to  iowdave
27, July 2018 3:01 pm

A Bridge, or Tunnel, to the Mainland is never going to happen since it would inevitably rely on EU funding, and frankly the islands road infrastructure could simply not cope with a sudden unregulated influx of traffic from the Mainland.

Far better to offer each island residential council tax paying household two free vehicle return journeys per year.

iowdave
Reply to  Alternative Perspective
27, July 2018 9:08 pm

I can’t see the free ticket option ever happening. Also, do you really consider that using the ferries “regulates the influx of traffic”? Also, what about the “unregulated” outflux of traffic. The anti-fixed link arguments can always be quashed.

Dalek
Reply to  iowdave
27, July 2018 9:40 pm

If you’re suggesting that the traffic will somehow magically “balance out” then you are deluded.

Sally Perry
Admin
Reply to  njb249
28, July 2018 9:46 am

Before this thread escalates into a discussion about a fixed link, please can I remind commenters there are plenty of articles about the fixed link where those discussions can take place. Thank you.

greenhey
27, July 2018 7:10 pm

Neither tunnel nor bridge will happen. There are too many financial and engineering hurdles. Even if they did, they would not reduce the ferry fares.
It’s time people on the island discounted that option and did some more challenging thinking

bbrown
27, July 2018 9:52 pm

Do not forget there are shortages of doctors and nurses UK wide which will get worse if the government does not get on top of the situation.

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined