Aerial view of the Island and Hampshire
Image: Mike McBey under CC BY 2.0

Hampshire, Portsmouth and Southampton leaders support Isle of Wight’s case for independence

Hampshire, Southampton, and Portsmouth councils have written to the Government to support the Isle of Wight’s position as a standalone unitary authority.

The letters sent to the Minister make clear that the Island should not be reorganised or merged with any other authority as part of the national Local Government Reorganisation (LGR) process — LGR is an entirely  different process to Devolution which does not require any changes to local authorities.

Government’s reorganisation plans
The Government has announced that local authorities across the country must submit outline plans for reorganisation in the Solent area by mid-March, with detailed proposals to follow by autumn 2025.

LGR aims to replace all two-tier local authority structures with single unitary authorities. However, as the Isle of Wight council is already a unitary authority, it does not require restructuring.

Isle of Wight makes the case for exemption
Councillor Phil Jordan, Leader of the Isle of Wight council, has repeatedly pressed the Minister and his team to ensure the Island remains unchanged.

Speaking today, he told OnTheWight,

“From the outset of the Government announcement on re-organisation I have been very clear with the Minister and his team of civil servants.

“I have met the Minister a number of times in the past two months and on each occasion I have put the case very firmly for the Island remaining as is, an unchanged status and size Unitary council, and received positive comments back about our position.”

He has followed up those meetings with a letter to the Minister, reinforcing the Island’s case for exception.

Regional councils stand with the Island
Councillor Jordan has worked closely with leaders from Portsmouth, Southampton, and Hampshire councils to present a united front against any changes to the Isle of Wight’s governance structure.

“As a strategic partnership, selected for the priority programme for devolution, the four Leaders of Portsmouth, Southampton, Hampshire and the Isle of Wight have written separately to the Minister, mapping out the proposals that support the Island in remaining unchanged and supporting the Island with its case for exception under the White Paper guidelines and LGR correspondence.”

The letters, now made available to residents below, demonstrate that local authorities in the region support the Island’s continued independence as a unitary authority.

Positive discussions with the Government
Councillor Jordan remains optimistic that the Minister will formally confirm the Isle of Wight’s exemption from reorganisation.

“To date, the discussions I have had are positive and the Minister accepts we have a special case for exception, and I am working hard to get him to commit to that in writing as soon as possible.”

“Further meetings with Government officials are scheduled in the coming weeks, both with Councillor Jordan and the Isle of Wight Council’s Chief Executive.

“I am confident that we can be successful in our ask of Government and move on through to Devolution unhindered by any re-organisation for the Island. I am not stopping until we achieve that goal.”

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
13 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Geoff Brodie
16, February 2025 3:25 pm

It is interesting that after I float the suggestion of a merger with a mainland council like Portsmouth in the IW Observer this week Phil has launched this media campaign to defend the IW Council’s independence. ‘Howls of protest’ indeed! I am sure that in reality he knows that the IW Council is a basket case, ripe for bankruptcy in the near future without significant government funding… Read more »

Merger
vitabrevis
Reply to  Geoff Brodie
16, February 2025 5:24 pm

Cllr Brodie ‘s ego is getting the better of him: this debate has been in progress for several weeks, long before his whinge in the IW Obsessor. Neither Cllr Jordan nor any of those of his peers who wrote to the Minister mentions IWC’s being unable to continue. For sure, Hants, Soton and Pompey don’t want us on board because they know perfectly well that our costs… Read more »

drone
Reply to  Geoff Brodie
17, February 2025 10:25 am

Give over Geoff, Phil Jordan has been banging on about fighting for the independence of the IW Council since the news emerged in December.

VentnorLad
16, February 2025 9:46 pm

Three larger local councils don’t want to take on the omnishambles left by years of incompetence and mismanagement by 39 squabbling clowns.

Who can blame them!?

The downside of this is that IWC will face yet more incompetence and mismanagement by 39 squabbling clowns.

The people who suffer most are the citizens of the Island.

Benny C
Reply to  VentnorLad
16, February 2025 10:17 pm

Frankly you’re being a tad disrespectful to clowns everywhere. They’re mostly honest, popular, smart, communicative, collaborative, quick thinking characters who often uphold high moral standards and principles in the way they conduct and perform their business. No trouser buying to be seen anywhere during a performance.

Benny C
16, February 2025 10:11 pm

Firstly, how awkward that Phil Jordan feels the need to set out at the start of his letter what services the IOWC provides. I would guess the Local Govt Minister probably has a fair idea alteady. How to misread the impact and send your audience attention into a tailspin. I doubt Phil actually wrote that letter but whoever composed it for him needs to be replaced by… Read more »

grahamg
17, February 2025 8:13 am

A choice between a rock and a hard place. Complete stand-alone autonomy for a council that has any kind of the semblance to the current one fills me with dread.
Being a small fish (the island) in a big sea (Soton, Pompey AND Hants) means barely any kind of say (we will be a small minority of councillors compared the rest).
Private Fraser comes to mind…..

Mark L Francis
17, February 2025 9:02 am

Remind me – did not Education & Children’s Services have to be taken over after the IWCC couldn’t run them satisfactorily on its own?

Geoff Brodie
Reply to  Mark L Francis
17, February 2025 9:33 am

Indeed. And until recently a Public Health Director from Hampshire. And the current Finance Director from Portsmouth.

Snowwolf1
17, February 2025 10:31 am

You have to live on the Island to understand the Island and it’s residents issues; so fully agree we do not want mainlanders joining in on what should and shouldn’t happen here. The only thing we need is when elections come round we do actually vote for those who sincerely care about the Island and its progression in betterment for all who live here not just their… Read more »

drone
17, February 2025 11:14 am

This is very reassuring to read. I’d like to also be reassured that the Island will see equity in the ‘strategic partnership’ that is formed.

Colin
17, February 2025 12:39 pm

The other councils realise that the Island is going to be a pain in the backside and don’t want to touch it with a barge pole.

peterspink10
17, February 2025 12:51 pm

There is scope in the White-Paper for the Island to remain as a stand-alone unitary authority with a negotiated bespoke devolution deal.
We would have to apply for it under a claim of an exceptional case, but as the saying goes, ‘don’t ask, don’t get!”

reCaptcha Error: grecaptcha is not defined