Red Box Project share disappointment at lack of support from Isle of Wight council (updated)

The Red Box Project have shared their disappointment that 21 Isle of Wight councillors chose not to support Cllr Lilley’s motion without it removing the name of the project. Here’s their response.

red box

Katharine Spencer-Brown, the Isle of Wight co-coordinator for the non-political, community-led Red Box Project, an initiative that aims to end period poverty in schools across the Island, shares this response following last week’s full council debate. Ed

The Red Box Project – Isle of Wight (RBP) would like to say ‘thank you’ to Cllr Michael Lilley (Independent Green) who proposed a motion at last Wednesday’s Isle of Wight Full Council Meeting (catch up here) to support the Red Box Project and to raise awareness of period poverty on the Island.

Cllr Lilley’s motion read:

Resolved that Isle of Wight Council supports the IW Red Box Project and campaign in their endeavour to raise awareness and tackle period poverty which results in an estimate of one in ten girls in IW schools not able to afford sanitary products through provision of free products in all schools across the Island.

Unexpected amendment
Despite his best efforts, he was unexpectedly faced with an amendment proposed by Cllr Chris Whitehouse (Conservative) which sought to remove from the motion the words ‘Red Box Project’.

The Council voted to accept the amended motion.

Spencer-Brown: Disappointed council voted not to support Cllr Lilley’s motion
Katharine Spencer-Brown, coordinator of the project said,

“It is wonderful to have the support of Cllr Lilley and I’m extremely grateful to him. By him bringing this motion, it has highlighted the issue of Period Poverty here on the Island as well as highlighting the kindness of the community who have, and continue, to donate menstrual items and appropriate pants to stock the Red Boxes.

“I am disappointed that the Council voted not to support the motion put forward by Cllr Lilley, but work continues and only today I delivered a further three Red Boxes to Schools in Ryde and East Cowes.”

Lilley: Cllr Brading keen to meet RBP leaders
Cllr Lilley said,

“IW Council Cabinet Members did state they supported Red Box Project including Cllr Brading, Cabinet Member for Children Services.

“What they were not prepared to do was agree to wording that identified a specific group, which was the whole point of my motion.

“However, Council Services such as the Library are taking donation boxes enthusiastically.

“Cllr Brading does want meet Red Box leaders. So some good outcomes.”

Find out more about the project by visiting the Facebook Page.

Following publication of the above, Independent councillor, Cllr Debbie Andre, told OnTheWight,

“I am bitterly disappointed that Cllr Whitehouse saw fit to try to gain cheap political capital by putting in an amendment which effectively removed the Red Box Project from the motion. I first became aware of the RBP and their sterling work in raising awareness of sanitary product poverty through the Inspiring Women Group of which I am a founder member.

“I raised the point that in taking their name out of the motion, it then became ineffectual as it was their ‘brand’ that people could identify with and which would encourage them to engage with this issue that is prevalent on our Island.

“It’s unclear what Cllr Whitehouse’s true intention was in acting in this way, but I believe the effect of his actions has been both negative and derogatory to Island women of all ages, who he plainly has no understanding of or regard for.

“I fully support Cllr Lilley and voted against the amendment for this reason. I will continue to both support and promote the Red Box Project.”

Image: Red Boxes being delivered to Ryde Academy

Saturday, 24th November, 2018 10:32am



Filed under: Island-wide, Isle of Wight Council, Isle of Wight News, Top story

Any views or opinions presented in the comments below must comply with the Commenting 'House Rules' and are solely those of the author and do not represent those of OnTheWight.

Leave your Reply

10 Comments on "Red Box Project share disappointment at lack of support from Isle of Wight council (updated)"

newest oldest most voted
Obviously an extremely worthwhile ‘project’ – even the generic brands of period products all add up to a lot of extra expense. On a side note, isn’t it awful that many islanders with so little money of their own have to give so much money to various charities, whilst meanwhile major corporations aren’t paying their money into the public purse? The poor support the poorer, through taxes,… Read more »
Geoff Brodie

To be absolutely clear – all the opposition to this Motion came from the Conservatives. The 10 in favour were 6 Indys, 2 LibDems, Cllr Lilley and myself.


So, vote out the Cons next time. They’ve had their day.


Ahh…so this is an issue of party membership then – now I understand…

Hang on a minute…didn’t Mr Lilley state that, “IW Council Cabinet Members did state they supported Red Box Project including Cllr Brading, Cabinet Member for Children Services”…so nothing to do with being a Conservative then..??? Not sure Mr Brodie here has a clue what’s going on….mind you – good excuse for having a pop at the Conservative party and Conservative Council members – Option 1 – climb… Read more »
Alternative Perspective

A prime example of the ‘nasty party’ in action.

Oust them all out in the next General and County Council Elections, they are simply not worthy to represent our island community.


Absolutely. They have to go, FB6, St Mary’s roundabout and how many moe F ups…


For me, the most shocking thing is that there are young women out there unable to even afford 66p for a pack of pads from Tescos.

This is the 21st century, not the 19th, after all.


I wonder how much support was from mens/ women? I wonder if more would have supported if they All had to endure periods ?


You might be surprised. There are men who understand and sympathise with the situation.