TwoWight: MPs Voted It Through Last Night

MPs last night voted for the Island to have two Island MPs.

TwoWightAs previewed by Andrew Turner yesterday, the MPs voted to split the Island constituency in two, not split the time of one of those MPs with the Mainland. This was seen as a concession to the Lords, who in January voted to keep the Isle of Wight separate.

Many on the Island felt that, with only one MP for the Isle of Wight, the people of the Island were under-represented as their vote counted for less, compared with other areas of the UK.

Back in August, VB put out an opinion piece arguing for two dedicated MPs for the Island, unpopular with some at the time. Some labelled the two Island MPs idea TwoWight.

Last night’s voting and other details are available from PA.

Before it becomes law, it still must be voted through the House of Lords.

Advertisement
Subscribe
Email updates?
31 Comments
oldest
newest most voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments
Vicky
16, February 2011 9:49 am

Where will they divide it, right down the middle?

Mike
Reply to  Vicky
16, February 2011 10:03 am

The boundary commission will need to find a line that leaves 52 500 residents on one side and 52 500 on the other.

DaveQ
16, February 2011 10:25 am

Which ever way its to be split, it will be the Boundary Commission rather than politicians who make the decision!
At last the Commons have voted sensibly- probably for the first time since last May!!

ABC
16, February 2011 10:52 am

Two points from last night Commons’ debate made me smile. A Labour MP criticised the Coalition Government for making a special case for the Island but not taking a similar line with constituencies in Cornall and Wales. He described it as not ‘gerrymandering’ but ‘ferrymandering’. And Andrew Turner received a sympathetic hearing from fellow MPs when he read from a prepared speech. He did, however, refer twice… Read more »

ABC
Reply to  ABC
16, February 2011 10:54 am

Make that Cornwall!

ABC
16, February 2011 11:03 am

Rather than getting into arguments over how the Island should be divided, why not have all candidates standing for the whole Island and the two who poll the most votes represent us all?

ABC
Reply to  Simon Perry
16, February 2011 11:23 am

Almost certainly not. But if a special case can be made for two MPs why not ask for this? I will not hold my breath, however.
I imagine the MP with the most votes would try to claim the ‘senior partner’ role.
I am sure there must be many other reasons for and against. Any thoughts anyone?

AK2UK
Reply to  ABC
17, February 2011 5:09 am

Sounds like a better solution than splitting the island. That’s how the US Senate works. Two senators for each state; both senators represent (and elected by / answerable to) the entire state.

Jane K
Reply to  ABC
17, February 2011 10:06 am

One ‘for’ for shared coverage of the Island would be competition (and a lot of collaboration) for doing best for the island. It would keep them both on their toes.

Stewart Blackmore
Reply to  Simon Perry
16, February 2011 10:31 pm

No Simon

Matt
16, February 2011 11:23 am

Unfortunately not-constituencies are geographically bounded.

No.5
Reply to  Matt
16, February 2011 11:53 am

great Idea but without any legal basis or precedent. The split is fairly clear East/west with a couple of central towns and villages drifting one way or the other.

stephen
16, February 2011 12:50 pm

Would new constituencies along the boundaries of the former Medina Council and the South Wight Council be another way of splitting the island?

No.5
Reply to  stephen
16, February 2011 1:02 pm

its all going to be about numbers

No.5
Reply to  No.5
16, February 2011 1:08 pm

My guess is Ryde to ventnor including Godshill on oneside..Newport an dthe rest on the other based on
2001 population figures

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/List_of_places_on_the_Isle_of_Wight

No.5
Reply to  No.5
16, February 2011 1:10 pm

probably have to go PFI for the wall though

watchdog
Reply to  No.5
16, February 2011 2:37 pm

Bravo, No 5, that really made me smile.

Paul Miller
Reply to  stephen
16, February 2011 1:21 pm

Probably not – the former MBC took in Ryde Newport and Cowes. ‘South wight’ went right across the Island. To get two ‘equal’ parts Ryde has to be in a separate constituency from Newport – else how is Ryde to gain from status quo. It’s the Island largest town in its own right. The best thing all round is if AT gets Newport [prisoners too!] Cowes [Both]… Read more »

John
16, February 2011 2:48 pm

TWO MPs, eh! What’s the betting that “Pugh, Pugh, Barney McGrew” will throw his hat into the ring- and 100,000 Islanders will throw it out again? :-))

Tired of the Westminster Twostep
16, February 2011 3:18 pm

People used to say that I was cynical of politicians, and then they realized that it wasn’t me who was cynical, but the politicians. Very few have proven themselves worthy of sacrifices made in the name of democracy, and certainly none on offer to me are worthy of my vote.   Even the relevancy of parliament is a very moot point indeed, as Tony Benn stated in… Read more »

John
Reply to  Tired of the Westminster Twostep
16, February 2011 3:39 pm

re: “I mean the £8-9-10 million a year that PFI is going to cost doesn’t grow on trees you know.”

Even if it did, selling off the UK’s national forests to investment (b)ankers ensures that it would not be scrumped by the poor. :-))

RTUC
Reply to  John
16, February 2011 3:54 pm

The principle advocated some time ago by the Trades Council that the island should be one entity with two MP’s appears to have gained currency.We wish to congratulate all of those, regardless of their political persuasion, who have gained this on behalf of the democratic citizens on the island. Now we must go forward and try and find those candidates, selected by various collectives on the island,… Read more »

watchdog
Reply to  Tired of the Westminster Twostep
16, February 2011 4:10 pm

TotWT: your quotations are awesome. Obviously, “History is just one damn thing after another”, most of it repeated.

montana sliver
16, February 2011 10:24 pm

Turners mum: What do you want to do when you grow up Andrew?

Turner: I’m going to be king of the Isle of White and Caroles going to be queen mummy

Turners mum: That nice dear, but I think you will only be king of half of it and I don’t think its not spelt like that either.

no.5
Reply to  montana sliver
16, February 2011 11:48 pm

:)

unconvinced
17, February 2011 1:54 pm

?more expensive? divisive? will our views now be ignored by twice as many MP’s as before?

no.5
Reply to  unconvinced
17, February 2011 3:30 pm

Thats for the electorate to decide and monitor

Don Smith
18, February 2011 9:55 am

The OneWight campaign only ever wanted one MP for the IoW. May I suggest that you look at their logo very carefully. Andrew Turner wrote: Date: 02 Nov 2010 ‘The Island’s MP, Andrew Turner, has said he is disappointed that the House of Commons voted last night to split the Island by a majority of 81.’ I attended the OneWight meeting and the majority of supporter of… Read more »

montana sliver
18, February 2011 10:43 am

For them to claim this as a victory Don is so ludicrous it should be entertaining, that is if it wasn’t such an insult to our intelligence.

M butcher
9, November 2012 12:31 pm

So two MP,s,claiming big expenses,to reprsent the Island Or will Andrew Turner only claim half as he only be representing half the Island.