Councillor Karl Love has announced his resignation from the Alliance Group of councillors at the Isle of Wight council, citing concerns over inclusivity and democratic processes.
The councillor, who represents East Cowes, stated his intention to sit as an Independent, working with those who share his values.
He expressed frustration with the handling of key decisions, particularly regarding the council’s approach to devolution.
Concerns over democratic process
In a statement to OnTheWight, Councillor Love criticised the Alliance Cabinet’s decision-making process, stating his view that it lacked proper consultation with local councils and residents.
He said,
“No doubt I will now become the target of the Alliance Cabinet for standing up for what I believe in… The people of our Island are not an afterthought.
“Their views should be front and centre, and even Town, Parish and community councils have not been consulted before committing and green-lighting this approach.
“Where is the democracy in that?”
Councillor Love expressed particular dissatisfaction with the Cabinet’s decision to apply for the Priority Programme, suggesting it was rushed and poorly considered.
Devolution and Island-specific challenges
Addressing the issue of devolution, Councillor Love argued that the Island’s unique circumstances had not been adequately considered. He highlighted the challenges posed by its physical connectivity and the potential implications of a mayoral role, including significant tax-raising powers and external influences on governance. He said,
“Devolution cannot operate on an Island in the same way it operates on the mainland.
“Our connectivity simply does not allow that sharing in the same way of physical services.
“We should be shouting for special circumstances, which is apparently an afterthought of this Cabinet.”
However, if the council are accepted on to the Priority Programme, they say the purpose is to be at the table early enough with negotiating powers to fight for the Island’s independence.
Resignation letter
In his resignation letter to Councillor Phil Jordan, Leader of the council, Councillor Love formally outlined his reasons for leaving the Alliance Group. He expressed disappointment in the perceived shift away from inclusivity and progressive values within the group.
He wrote,
“The Alliance group in my view is no longer inclusive and representative of my political views as was once the case.
“I believe the Alliance has become a group of Cabinet determination which excludes and exhibits behaviours I cannot support.”
Jordan: It’s a shame he did not share his concerns with me before making a final decision
In response, Councillor Phil Jordan told OnTheWight,
“I think I can speak for everyone in the Alliance when I say we wish Councillor Love well for the future. On the reasons he has indicated that he left the Alliance, devolution may be confusing, but with thirty-nine other Local Authorities all who have indicated the same direction of travel, it is a shame he did not share his concerns with me before making a final decision. Had he done so, he would have had a fuller understanding of the whole process. The Alliance, as does the leader of the Conservative Group and other Council members, believe it is in the Island’s best interests, understanding that a final decision on a Strategic Partnership under Devolution will be made at Full Council later this year.
“It was noted in his resignation letter that he ‘believed that there was a genuine attempt to be progressive, but sadly that determination has evaporated’. I disagree with that fundamentally and note some of the progressive successes over the last 12 months and what is coming forward now, as a result of continued determination and progressive commitments.
“All Alliance members are dedicated to those they represent, working diligently and with determination to get the job done. Council wheels often move at a slower pace than we would all like, but that does not mean that progression is not made or that it dampens the resolve. His reasoning for departure, I do not believe is shared within the Alliance group, but, its respected, and we wish him the best for his future.”
Full council decision
Councillor Love criticised what he described as the Cabinet’s failure to secure a public mandate or consult Town and Parish Councils before committing to devolution. He emphasised that this rushed decision-making could have significant electoral and governance implications for the Island.
Councillor Jordan has reiterated many times that any final decision on devolution would go before the Full Council.
Commitment to East Cowes
Despite his resignation, Councillor Love confirmed his intention to continue serving as Chairman until re-election in May 2025, pledging to oversee his duties with fairness. He concluded,
“I remained in the Alliance because I believed that there was a genuine attempt to be progressive, inclusive, and representative of all peoples and councillors across the board. Sadly, that determination has evaporated.”
Article edit
8.20pm 17th Jan 2025 – PJ comment added
Catch up on the latest in relation to the Devolution plans by accessing OnTheWight’s Solent Devolution archive. Ed
