Row erupts over Westridge Farm development after landowner writes to Isle of Wight council leader

The landlord, Robert Ball, says the media coverage of about the tenant farmers is “not a fair or accurate representation of the situation”. They refute the claims and counter it to “ensure total transparency”

letter in envelope on a desk

A row has broken out between the landowner of Westridge Farm and the tenant farmers, the Holliday family.

In a letter (seen by News OnTheWight) to the leader of the Isle of Wight council – Cllr Dave Stewart – and copied to all councillors, the landlord and owner since 1988, Robert Ball of Arnbrow Ltd, said that he felt the media coverage of the position of the tenant farmers, in particular a recent broadcast on BBC South Today, was “not a fair or accurate representation of the situation”.

Dispute over settlement
Mr Ball states in his letter that a commercial settlement of £800,000, plus 50 acres of farmland, was agreed in August 2109, but that the tenant farmers then insisted on £1m settlement instead.

Mr Ball said the £800k offer was accepted and confirmed in writing, but the Hollidays – in a statement they released on their Save Westridge Farm Facebook Page yesterday (Monday) – countered that by saying,

“An £800,000 offer was put forward by Robert Ball of Arnbrow Ltd, meaning vacating Westridge Farm completely.

“We did consider this with the assistance of our land agent and solicitor and we did put forward a counter offer of £1m.

“This value was based on relocating to another dairy farm, which we would have had to invest in heavily.”

Payment over four years
The Hollidays went on to say that the payment terms of the settlement was actually over four years, with the first payment not being received until after they had vacated the farm – giving them no ability to buy another farm to move on to.

The family went on to explain that the landlord has stated that through a clause in the current tenancy, they will seek to remove five acres every quarter as soon as planning permission is granted.

They say,

“The first five acres will include the farmhouse and farm buildings. This will mean the end to dairy farming at Westridge Farm, as we will simply be unable to continue without suitable farm buildings to house our cattle, a dairy and a home to live in.”

Lilley: 50 acres is not enough
Cllr Michael Lilley, who has been a strong advocate of the tenant farmers, told News OnTheWight that the Hollidays had been completely open and transparent throughout the process.

He added that the offer of 50 acres of farmland was not sufficient to run a dairy farm on, stressing the importance of needing to find another farm on the Island to protect their livelihoods and generations of farming.

Cllr Lilley went on to say that farmland is costed on average at around £8,000-£12,000 per acre, but with planning permission this can rise by 30 times. On a farm such as Westridge, this would put the value of the land at around £24 million.

Holliday: Protecting and safeguarding land for future generations
In their statement, the Hollidays finished by saying,

“Our hope is that planning will not be granted, so we can continue to dairy farm at Westridge Farm, protecting and safeguarding this land for the good of future generations.”

West Acre Park
Mr Ball ended his letter to Cllr Stewart by saying he hoped it would ensure an informed and balanced decision when the West Acre Park proposal is presented for planning determination.

The planning committee can, of course, only consider material planning objections when determining an application.

A revised application has been submitted by Captiva Homes, the developer planning to build 475 homes on the farmland.

You can read the Holliday’s statement in full on their Facebook page.

Image: maxbraun under CC BY 2.0

Tuesday, 17th November, 2020 2:44pm



Filed under: Isle of Wight Council, Isle of Wight News, Planning, Ryde, Isle of Wight, Top story

Any views or opinions presented in the comments below must comply with the Commenting 'House Rules' and are solely those of the author and do not represent those of OnTheWight.

Leave your Reply

6 Comments on "Row erupts over Westridge Farm development after landowner writes to Isle of Wight council leader"

newest oldest most voted

Would Arnbrow Ltd consider selling the farm and land to a community group at a reasonable price in the same way that Fordhall Farm in Shropshire was bought by the community after fund-raising? This would keep it as farm land and not for housing. I for one would be willing to buy shares in such a group.

It is just madness to keep filling in Ryde, which already suffers a multitude of infrastructure problems, where there are massive tracts of land elsewhere. The artificial scarcity of land which generates massive wealth for a chosen few whilst cramming the rest of us in ever tighter is a serious societal problem. Yet it hardly gets discussed. Clearly an ever increasing population means we need more houses… Read more »
Eagle eye
Feudal lord throwing peasants crumbs then has a tantrum when they don’t pick them up. What is implied is the expectation that planning permission will be granted hence writing to the all the councillors. I believe, all that is coming through is the council’s involvement in pushing this application through regardless. It seems to explain why all the delegated decisions were made for the enabling of Hope… Read more »
Benny C

So the poor old farmer had actually accepted an offer of a million quid. Slightly different perspective. Invested well that would net around £1000 per week to live on. I reckon I could do that and not have to work. If the farm had meant that much and his lease gave him long term teeth he would have fought.


£52k after tax on £1m invested. I’d like to know where you can get that rate of return, I would move my pension fund as I make that requiring well over 5.5% gross return.

Not as clear cut as you make out. The offer apparently accepted was £800,000 over 4 years (was it also dependent on % of development completed as these sort of deals often are?) and they would have to vacate immediately. So factor in lost of home and job. Also I don’t believe you’d get anything like that, interest rate wise. They are currently at a historic low… Read more »