Nick Stuart and dog

‘It’s been a long time coming’ says new LibDem councillor after landslide victory (updated)

It’s fifth time lucky for a Liberal Democrat, Cllr Nick Stuart, as he secures a landslide victory in Brighstone, Calbourne and Shalfleet, winning a seat on the Isle of Wight Council.

Top of the by-election poll last night (Thursday), he gained more than 50 per cent of the vote – and finished nearly 290 votes ahead of Conservative candidate Carol Bryan.

The ward has been held by the Conservatives since 2011.

The by-election followed the resignation of senior Tory, Steve Hastings.

Stuart: It’s been a long time coming
Speaking after his win, Cllr Stuart said he was very pleased.

He said,

“It has been a long time coming. I have stood four times previously, unsuccessfully.

“The critical thing is to listen to voters, understand what the issues are and put that forward, with the values we hold.”

He added the campaign had been a lot of work by Isle of Wight Liberal Democrats.

Listening to residents’ concerns
Cllr Stuart said concerns raised with him in the run-up to the election campaign had included speeding, over-development,  sewerage and drainage.

He added the result was, at least in part, a message to both the government and the Isle of Wight council,

“Everybody I spoke to, including Conservatives, said, ‘I used to vote X but I don’t know what to do now.’

“The problem is they have no faith in central government.”

Stuart: Alliance moving in the right direction
Cllr Stuart also said County Hall’s leading Alliance administration was trying hard and moving in the right direction but, it was felt, not fast enough.

He did not rule out the possibility of joining the Alliance, but said it would be subject to a discussion with fellow Liberal Democrat, Cllr Andrew Garratt.

Garratt: A magnificent candidate
Cllr Garratt said he felt absolutely elated.

He called Cllr Stuart a magnificent candidate, really embedded in the community and noted his hard work with the two parish councils in the ward — Brighstone Parish Council and Calbourne, Newtown and Porchfield Parish Council.

He said ensuring Islanders are supported through the cost of living crisis would be their first priority, along with ensuring a sensible Island Planning Strategy is passed, protecting the council’s need to provide affordable properties at a price Islanders can afford to rent or buy.

The results
The full results of the by-election were:

  • Nick Stuart, Liberal Democrat – 526 votes
  • Carol Bryan, Local Conservatives – 239 votes
  • Doug Alldred, The Green Party – 153 votes
  • Stephen J Parkes, Vectis Party – 36 votes
  • Gary Clarke, Labour Party – 31 votes

Article edit
9.31am 25th Nov 2022 – The LDR used the wrong ward to determine previous election results. Brighstone has been held by the Conservatives since 2005 but the other areas were Conservative from 2011. The article has been changed accordingly 


This article is from the BBC’s LDRS (Local Democracy Reporter Service) scheme, which News OnTheWight is taking part in. Some alterations and additions may have been made by OnTheWight. Ed